3 ms·
The difference between China's democides/labor camps/external aggression and North Korea's democides/labor camps/external aggression is largely that China got r
by patio11 17y ago
The difference between China's democides/labor camps/external aggression and North Korea's democides/labor camps/external aggression is largely that China got rich doing it and North Korea got poor. (Well, "rich", at any rate. About 10% of China is a fast growing dynamic economy which has eventual aspirations of being a world power -- and the other 90% lives in grinding poverty.)
Anyhow, since China is rich, it is considered sort of impolite to say "China, please stop committing genocide" or "Hey, China, working people to death in your laogai camps is sort of uncool." (This is sort of related to how it was tres gauche to mention that Soviet Russia was a brutal, genocidal dictatorship and how a huge portion of the American and European intelligensia supported that model and wanted it for their own countries. Which is itself related to it earlier being quite undiplomatic to talk about what the Austrian chap was doing in addition to his economic reforms.)
Be that as it may, reluctance to confront evil in China should not lead to reluctance to confront evil in North Korea.
- maxklein 17y agoThat's a very japanese point of view you have there. Why does nobody speak of the exploitation of china (nanjing massacre, etc) as part of what made Japan rich.
- patio11 17y agoPeople do discuss Japanese wartime atrocities. Frequently. It would have been a bad example for the above post, though, because people actually opposed Japan's conduct in Manchuria contemporaneously (whereas China's conduct in the status quo, the Soviet Union's conduct for its entire existence, and the first few years of German fascism were/are dealt with limp-wristedly when they were not actively applauded). For example, the United States hit Japan with a steel/oil embargo after Japanese refused to withdraw from Manchuria, which was the proximate cause of Japan deciding to go to war with the United States. (Funny little historical note: the US didn't actually intend the embargo to be a total embargo. When it was conceived in Washington it was as a temporary cutback to force Japan to the negotiating table. A minor bureaucrat misfiled something, though, and the planned periodic review never happened, which turned it into a total embargo. "Whoops.") As an aside, essentially none of Japan's present economic prosperity is owed to wealth stolen from China. Most of that got very comprehensively burned, along with the rest of the country. Japan was pretty desperately poor postwar prior to the US' Korean war buildup, which they largely sourced in Japan, re-laying the industrial base which ignited the Period of High Economic Growth (高度成長期) that brought Japan from "substantially poorer than Mexico" to "really freaking rich". Apologies for the lecture.
- elblanco 17y ago>...and North Korea got poor It might be an interesting study to see if North Korea actually just slowed down the collapse via slave labor vs. actually contributing.