5 ms·
Why not shutter the pre-pivot startup and apply as a fresh startup to YC? If the idea, business model, and pitch are completely different, is it actually the s
by nostrademons 11y ago
Why not shutter the pre-pivot startup and apply as a fresh startup to YC? If the idea, business model, and pitch are completely different, is it actually the same company?
- jeffwass 11y agoSo you're advocating screwing over the investors from the first accelerator? Especially after they guided the startup to a potentially successful pivot?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoIt depends on the situation. If your new business plan is encumbered by associations with the previous "pivot" (usually: because you share code with it), then starting fresh is problematic. But if it's not, if the only thing that's the same with the previous pivot is the team, and iff you haven't worked on the new business plan using resources from the previous investors, then "pivoting" gives your previous investors equity in a business they had nothing to do with starting. If you were (a) about to run out of money anyways after giving it an honest shot or (b) returning money back to the investors, there's nothing wrong with dissolving old-co and starting new-co with a clean cap table.
- rachellaw 11y agoWe've already taken investment pre-pivot from angels, screwing investors over to be a 'fresh startup' seems to be a type of fraud. It's different pitch, but a natural and logical progression. Most of the time ideas need refining, especially with user feedback. It doesn't make sense to start with a new company since the technology that powers is still the same.
- nostrademons 11y agoIf the IP is the same, it makes sense to continue with the existing company. The IP belongs to the company, which belongs to the shareholders. If you're changing everything, then it makes sense to just start a new company.
- ScottBurson 11y agoSam's relevant comment upthread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10941276 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10941276 So I guess it can be a judgment call. In your case it sounds like you're doing the right thing, though.
- rachellaw 11y agoone of the things that really struck me when fundraising: "...that 25k he just gave you, could've gone to his kids' college fund or investing in blue chip stocks instead. It's amazing that you can raise money at all." Angels give less money than VCs, some angels give low amounts (15-25k) especially in an early seed round. They're doing it for you. Screwing them over for more equity or YC makes you a shitty irresponsible human being and imho, should be considered a type of fraud. Honestly I'm surprised at Sam's stance. Unless it's really justifiable, this seems like bad advice.
- meric 11y agoIt sounds like you are doing the right thing.
- biot 11y agoOn the flip side, an investor puts money into funding an idea which they (ought to) know has a 90% chance of not working out. I don't see anything morally or ethically wrong with saying "I/we gave it our best, but the idea didn't pan out" and returning any leftover funds, if any, before completely flushing that idea (discarding all assets associated with it), putting your thinking cap on, and looking for the next opportunity. I generally don't see a problem with starting over if you're going from an "Uber for Drones" idea to a "Custom CNC Furniture" idea, for example. Of course, that's a completely different scenario from simply evolving the idea in a different direction but still keeping the core; in that case, I agree with your point of view. For example, I do see a problem if you're going from a "Custom CNC Furniture" idea to a "Custom CNC Cycling Parts" idea. It would be pretty shady to screw over your initial investors in that scenario. It also might be actionable by the original investors if you reuse any assets you developed using their funds.
- 11y ago