3 ms·
I'd also observe that in terms of prior probability, "There is a ninth planet in the solar system that we have not yet detected" is probably hovering at least i
by jerf 11y ago
I'd also observe that in terms of prior probability, "There is a ninth planet in the solar system that we have not yet detected" is probably hovering at least in the low-integer percentages, and I imagine some scientists would place it higher than that. The general idea is not a wild, far-out one by any stretch of the imagination.
- XorNot 11y agoThat isn't how probability works though. You have a Bayesian priors problem - you can't establish what the initial probabilities are.
- jerf 11y agoI can put some bounds on them, which is all I tried to do. It is certainly not reasonable to act as if the idea there is a ninth undetected planet is some sort of one-in-a-trillion possibility. I'm not even convinced you're correct anyhow; since I tend to accept the interpretation of probability as a statement of our knowledge of the world as good enough most of the time, we can establish a reasonable probability statement that expresses that uncertainty. We don't know everything about the universe or even our solar system but there is something about this topic that makes people start grossly overstating our ignorance.