5 ms·
What amazes me is that people can't imagine how primitive the world must have been 45,000 years ago. How far back does recorded history go? 6000-8000 years? 60
by melling 11y ago
What amazes me is that people can't imagine how primitive the world must have been 45,000 years ago. How far back does recorded history go? 6000-8000 years? 600 years ago most humans thought the world was flat.
There's some crazy statistic that 80% of Americans live within 50 or 100 miles where they were born.
- ashark 11y ago> There's some crazy statistic that 80% of Americans live within 50 or 100 miles where they were born. Family/social ties are a hell of a thing.
- mc32 11y agoI think the narrative that most humans thought the world was flat would be like 600 years hence people thinking most humans in 2016 believed climate change to be a conspiracy. What we have is surviving evidence from a few people thought the world flat. But that evidence does not necessarily reflect popular belief. Also for people inland, they may not even have had a reason to entertain the idea at all. That is most people may not have even considered the question. Obviously lots of early seafaring peoples held no such beliefs. Greeks, Phoenicians, Vikings, middle eastern traders, chinese traders, etc...
- melling 11y agoSo, 70% thought the world was round? http://environment.yale.edu/climate-communication/article/american-opinions-on-global-warming-a-yale-gallup-clearvision-poll http://environment.yale.edu/climate-communication/article/am... You would have thought countries would have claimed the New World a lot earlier.
- boxy310 11y agoThe main skepticism regarding Columbus was that they knew the Earth was much larger than what Columbus was projecting. It would be a generation before we had the technology and infrastructure to circumnavigate the globe by piggybacking off islands and friendly ports; to attempt to do so over what was assumed to be completely open waters in 1492 was tantamount to suicide. If Columbus hadn't stumbled upon the Bahamas when he did, his crew very likely would've died.
- freshyill 11y agoOr hit the mainland in a few more days. But I think your point was that they would have died had they not hit land of some kind before too much longer.
- warfangle 11y agoMore like everyone did. The myth that people thought the earth was flat has been attributed to Washington Irving (late 18th/early 19th century author & historian). Columbus actually thought the earth was pear-shaped and 1/3 of the size that everyone since the Ancient Greeks knew it to be. The issue was not "we'll fall off the edge of the earth." The issue was "Holy cow, you're going to try and sail 13,000 nautical miles?"
- mc32 11y agoTotally forgot about the xviii cent flat earth movement who popularized the "theory". Iirc, that's the main source if disinformation regarding the shape of Earth, rather than ancients believing such.
- beat 11y agoHistorically, the ancient Greeks knew Earth was round. Pythagoras and Aristotle documented that belief, and Erostothanes actually measured the circumference quite precisely. Pythagoras and Aristotle were well known to every educated mind in Europe at the time. Among the illiterate masses, flat earth might have been a thing.
- vidarh 11y agoTo add to this, while as you say, it's possible flat earth might have been a thing amongst the illiterate, we have lots and lots of evidence that shows that the idea of a spherical earth had not been forgotten in Europe at the time either (with numerous older sources, but just to specifically address "600 years ago...): Dante's Divine Comedy, finished in 1320, for example, goes into a lot of detail about the difference between the hemispheres such as how it affects which stars are visible and the concept of time difference and where he imagines the sun rises and sets over different parts of the world, and how gravity changes as Dante travels through the earth to arrive at other side. It's first four known printed editions incidentally all pre-date Columbus first voyage, being published in 1472, 1477, 1482 and 1491 in Foligno, Venice and Florence, and adding up to hundreds of copies. We also know that Columbus had read Claudius Ptomely's work, as well as Pierre d'Ailly's Imago Mundi which depicts the world as a globe. For some books we know this specifically because he owned printed editions and scribbled extensively in the margins. These books were circulated in some numbers: Columbus did not have to dig up obscure hand written copies or somehow otherwise come across old, forgotten knowledge that nobody else had. He grow up at a time when Italian publishers were churning out rapidly increasing numbers of copies of classical texts all over the place, and works by authors like Ptolemy and d'Ailly (and Dante) who explicitly described the world as round were printed in multiple editions and sought after. We also known that Ptolemy's work had been sought after in Europe for hundreds of years before that, with adaptations of his Geography, which reflects a round earth, regularly being made and amended and updated with additional information. The first printed edition of his Geography to include engraved maps was made in Bologna in 1477.
- siphor 11y agoI like the comparison, maybe there was even a political reason for telling people they'd fall off the earth if they tried to go somewhere..
- beat 11y agoDepends on what you mean by "primitive". 45,000 years ago, humans were every bit as intelligent as they are today. They may not have had agriculture or other technological advances, but mentally, they were sophisticated. Look at it this way... using only stuff they found on the ground, they were able to successfully and repeatably hunt animals that weighed 5-8 tons, were faster than humans, had multiple natural weapons that could easily kill a human, and were both herd-oriented and highly intelligent by herbivore standards. Do you think you could do that? That doesn't sound primitive to me. That sounds really sophisticated.
- Retric 11y agoGenetically that's more or less true. However, developmentally they were likely to suffer from various issues that limit intelligence. Things like poor diet/starvation, parasites, and limited socialization can have a dramatic impact.
- beat 11y agoBut what if they weren't starving? What if they had a rich social structure, where children could learn from directly observing their leaders? I'm not convinced they were starving "cavemen". If they couldn't cut it, Mother Nature would just kill them off - unlike modern, "civilized" people. They had better use of their brains than we do in day-to-day survival.
- melling 11y agoYou are not using facts to prove your point. It's basically the same sort of ignorance that people use to deny global warming. "I not convinced that humans can change the climate". If you have some facts that you'd like to share, please do. Making up really clever shit that can't be verified doesn't help. In fact, it could be the same human flaw that explains why it took us 45,000 years to get where we are today. Am I in the middle of a fuck wad nerd debate? I time travel 45,000 years into the past. Will I be able to survive? If not that proves humans were just as smart then as they are now. Where's that pg "Life is Short" article?
- 11y ago
- pound 11y ago> There's some crazy statistic that 80% of Americans live within 50 or 100 miles where they were born. what is crazy about it? or wrong?