6 ms·
I think that people are far too pessimistic and have lost sight of the end goal. The goal is not to create productivity. The goal is to create leisure. And,
by bsder 11y ago
I think that people are far too pessimistic and have lost sight of the end goal.
The goal is not to create productivity. The goal is to create leisure. And, so far, we've done a really shitty job of that.
- x5n1 11y agoThat's the thing, we were all supposed to be living luxurious lives, instead we're working 60 hour work weeks. And the elite think that more of that should be in store for us, you know because the economy just isn't doing all that well. Mainly because they are busy disrupting everything and automating it, using massive piles of capitals they have amassed on our backs to coerce us to work harder and produce more with less money -- productivity. With automation they need less of our work, so we should work more for less, while the capital they have amassed does most of the work through automation. Logically nothing we do as a species makes sense unless looked through the logic of economics, consumption, and production. It's a system with its own logic and we are so conditioned to think in its terms that we can think of no other way of organizing people and/or work. The best days for America was the American Dream as George Carlin said you have to dreaming to believe it. It was simply a hope that more of that money would trickle down to pretty much anyone if they worked hard enough. That hope is no longer there. No matter which way you frame it.
- FreedomToCreate 11y agoPretty Cynical there. Its really all about perspective. Look at this. As we continue to automate things, we reduce the time and effort required to manufacture the things we need. This creates an immense amount of leisure time. As we focus on creating social systems which provide basic income and living needs, we are currently on trajectory for a system where people can choose to do whatever they want, with complete leisure. All need for food and devices is sustained by machines, we are provided with all basic needs by the government and you can do whatever your heart desires. Now people may think that is pointless, but imagine what people could accomplish with the ability to pursue anything they want. There is 7 billion people on this planet. Its impossible to expect everyone achieving the american dream through sheer handwork.
- x5n1 11y ago> This creates an immense amount of leisure time. As we focus on creating social systems which provide basic income and living needs, we are currently on trajectory for a system where people can choose to do whatever they want, with complete leisure. Could yes, but will it, maybe in the long run. In my lifetime, basic income will be exactly that, basic. Enough for probably shelter and food. You know people living off food stamps, see how much luxury they have. That is still tied to the economy. Most of the income generated will go to the people who own the machines that produce that output. The sort of optimism you were talking about Adam Smith talked about, it never happened in Capitalism. Despite the fact that we solved a lot of automation problems of producing food, shelter, and material goods around the 1940s. The government only has so much money it can give out. Divide the entire world's GDP by the population and you get 11,038. So if we could do that we can all live on 11,000 a year. That would be in the case that you took away the money from private interest and implemented something like Communism globally. That's not going to happen. The elites will cause massive wars before their give up their strangle hold and control on the world. Private interests will hold on to the money and make people work for it, as they always have.
- kefka 11y agoIf the means of production were in the hands of the citizens, then there's no reason to make "profit". And if the production was completely automated, then everything would be easy to obtain and at very low cost. Now, we don't have to take away production facilities from companies or individuals, although progressive taxation is probably a good idea. Instead, the federal Govt already owns a great deal of land. We could urge to start developing on a small portion of that, for the needs of all the citizens. This isn't a communist/socialist/capitalist issue. We've been ignoring other economic systems for 2 centuries now, and flirted with communism back in the 20's. It's time to see what's out there that matches with our current technology.
- kefka 11y agoPoor people don't make enough money for companies to target effectively. Poor people also do not have the skills to make them employable- as in the minimum requirements for a human life are not equal to what their economic output is. Automation also provides a significant downward thrust lowering wages and sending people to unemployment or unemployability. This causes the the non-higher classes to be slowly, inexorably be shoved further down, thus creating more in the lower classes. Therefore, the longer we go, the more poor people (per capita) will exist. And poor people will continue to be dismissed, other than hand-wavy good intentions that really fail to solve the issue at hand. Once this cycle goes long enough, then that is the beginning of a national collapse, ala Depression. (No money to do things, no way to get money.)
- zbyte64 11y agoThe only hope left is to reform the political system.
- kefka 11y agoOne discussion on that topic is that Ted Cruz wishes to initiate a Constitutional Convention over various perceived issues. Given the recent contentious passed bills and judgements (PPACA, Gay Marriage, et al.), a convention of this type would split the country into factions. If that happens, I have a bad feeling about this country, and that goes along the lines of a civil war. Everything seems already so factioned already, and that their candidate is of the devil.
- oldmanjay 11y agoI often find myself wondering if Cruz actually expects that the federal government would pay any more attention to new amendments. It's already remarkably manipulative about what it considers relevant now. Any system that requires precise language laid down by "scholars" to justify stepping around what reads differently in plain English is clearly not a system that anyone is shy about gaming anyway.
- rconti 11y ago60 hour work weeks? Citation needed. Every time we talk about work, people overinflate their workweeks by including commuting time or that one time they checked their work email from their phone. 5x12 is hardly the norm.
- x5n1 11y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/on-leadership/wp/2014/09/02/the-average-work-week-is-now-47-hours/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/on-leadership/wp/2014/09... Let's split that and say 50.
- jseliger 11y agoAnd, so far, we've done a really shitty job of that. That's somewhat true because housing restrictions in major coastal cities have become so draconian, raising prices; moving to cheap places like Texas, Phoenix, or Atlanta is one way to increase leisure over consumption. But there may be other issues around the productivity hits that dividing up brainwork creates: http://jakeseliger.com/2016/01/09/the-more-you-do-it-the-better-you-get-why-americans-might-not-work-less http://jakeseliger.com/2016/01/09/the-more-you-do-it-the-bet....
- apocalyptic0n3 11y agoAs someone looking to buy their first house in Phoenix, it startles me that you think Phoenix is cheap. I'm accustomed to the metro-Detroit housing market (which is doing far better than Detroit-proper and has mostly recovered from the recession) and the prices here are hard to see myself paying. A house I would have expected to pay ~$200k for is listed at $310k, as an example.
- notacoward 11y agoIt's all relative. Sure, Phoenix is expensive compared to Detroit, but that doesn't mean it can't also be cheap compared to Boston, Seattle, NYC, DC, or just about anywhere in California. http://www.kiplinger.com/tool/real-estate/T010-S003-home-prices-in-100-top-u-s-metro-areas/index.php http://www.kiplinger.com/tool/real-estate/T010-S003-home-pri...
- rconti 11y agoSorry, but that's cheap. $1400/mo (assuming 10% down) for a mortgage on an entire house? That's cheap. That's marginally above apartment pricing in even non-high-end areas.
- WildUtah 11y agoAnd that $310k house will cost $1200k in LA or $2100k in SF, but with less land.
- khedoros 11y agoFor $310k, I'd expect about a 1000 sqft 2 bedroom condo in my area. The smallest single family homes are about 1200 sqft for about $500k, located on a postage stamp of land.
- ajessup 11y agoThis is because efficiency gains are channeled into improving overall productivity rather than reducing work required. This in turn is driven by global competition.
- ojbyrne 11y agoI don't think that's correct. Leisure isn't much good if it's due to unemployment and you're living at the subsistence level. What you're looking for, is "standard of living." And the part they're not really making explicit, is that economists have long accepted as a truism, that the best predictor of "standard of living" is productivity.
- madaxe_again 11y agoSo slaves who are highly productive for fear of their life, or even chattel-workers (I.e. Most folks) who likewise produce for fear of the bread line... They have a high standard of living? I call shenanigans. The best predictor for having a high standard of living is having a high standard of living. Also, define "standard". The most universal standard I can consider is leisure.
- ojbyrne 11y agoI should have added "as a country" in there somewhere. Obviously slaves or chattel workers can raise the average standard of living of a group as a whole, if you include their masters. Assuming that that system of labor is actually "highly productive" which I don't think I agree with.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- SixSigma 11y agoSo the proletariat should rise up and seize the means of leisure. Suggest a 4 day week and people think you've lost your mind.