5 ms·
And yet California has the most gun related deaths annually [1], even though it has one of the lowest percentages of gun ownership [1]. It just goes to show (i
by Alupis 11y ago
And yet California has the most gun related deaths annually [1], even though it has one of the lowest percentages of gun ownership [1].
It just goes to show (in part) that legal gun ownership isn't really the main issue we have.
We forget to include the 2/3 of national gun related deaths that are suicides [2]. These people need help; surely many of those victims would still have committed suicide had they not obtained a firearm.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States_by_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_Sta...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gun_violence_in_the_United_Sta...
- thrownaway2424 11y agoHuh? I don't know if you've realized this, but California is the most populous state. If you want to make your analysis more relevant (and less totally idiotic) you need to look at the rate per capita.
- Alupis 11y agoCalifornia doesn't fare much better even with per capita rates. The notions stands, reducing legal gun ownership has little effect on reducing gun related homicides. Gun related suicides are the real problem (~20,000 out of the total ~30,000 annual USA gun related deaths). Nobody is focusing on that issue.
- HoHoHoNowIHaveA 11y agoYour premise is only applicable to US states. It is not applicable to nation-states which demonstrate considerable effect in reducing gun-related homicides. Even more so when discounting individual lone-wolf attacks of a terrorist nature (Brevik, Norway). I could post sources but they are beyond dispute at this stage. (United Kingdom, Japan, Australia and most of the Western world). Evidence is also lent by the nation-states with lax gun control legislation which dominate the league table of gun-related homicides, of which, the USA is one.
- knowaveragejoe 11y agoThe idea that 20,000 deaths per year is a "real problem" while 10,000 per year is not is disingenuous at best. If the US had the same amount of gun violence in a day that the UK experiences in a year, it would be worldwide news.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 11y agoIt's 1/10 of the population of the country. It does more of almost everything than other states. The gun murder rate is in the top half, but solidly middle of the pack.
- Someone1234 11y ago> It just goes to show (in part) that legal gun ownership isn't really the main issue we have. It doesn't show that. You linked to a page that specifically had per capita murder rates (link [1]) and intentionally ignored it to make a point (since your point makes no sense if you look at per capita rates).
- Alupis 11y agoWhat the links show, is that suicide is the real problem the United States has. Two thirds (2/3) of all gun related deaths in the United States are suicides. That's roughly 20,000 gun related suicides annually. The odds of being killed in a mass public shooting are about 1 in 7,800,000[1]. Compared to your chances of being struck by lighting (about 1 in 1,000,000)[2], this is exceedingly rare. Legal gun ownership is not our problem. Suicide clearly is, and we cannot be so naive to believe reducing the number of guns in the country will have any real effect on reducing the number of suicides. Sure, we'll see a decrease in gun related suicides... but the suicides will still occur, just with an alternate method. These people need help, yet we're ignoring them because it's far easier to get riled up about people owning guns than it is to care about some faceless person committing suicide. [1] http://www.psychlawjournal.com/2013/01/school-shootings-what-are-odds-part-iii.html http://www.psychlawjournal.com/2013/01/school-shootings-what... [2] http://discovertheodds.com/what-are-the-odds-of-being-struck-by-lightning/ http://discovertheodds.com/what-are-the-odds-of-being-struck...
- OopsCriticality 11y ago> Sure, we'll see a decrease in gun related suicides... but the suicides will still occur, just with an alternate method. Suicide attempts by any method might be practically constant; alternate methods of suicide tend to be less successful however, so the rate of completed suicides would likely go down.
- Alupis 11y ago> alternate methods of suicide tend to be less successful however, so the rate of completed suicides would likely go down I don't see how that could be measured as a success. You still have mass amounts of people attempting to end their life every year. Essentially we're all busy trying to treat the obvious symptoms, but we're ignoring the real cause of our problems. Reducing legal gun ownership merely shifts the problem to another metric, but does not solve it. Solve our suicide problem in the United States, and we've solved our gun problem (among others). (this hinges on the fact that there is some level of annual deaths that society considers reasonable and acceptable, as-is with any activity)
- meisterbrendan 11y agoGuns make suicide attempts more deadly. Places with fewer guns do have proportionally more deaths from other types of suicide attempts, but the overall suicide levels are still substantially lower. Suicide ruminations may be frequent, but suicide attempts are often impulsive. http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/magazine-features/guns-and-suicide-the-hidden-toll/ http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/magazine-features/guns-and-suici... http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2013/12/gun_ownership_causes_higher_suicide_rates_study_shows.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/crime/2013/1... Your point about CA having the most gun deaths falls flat: CA has far and away the most people in the US. Gun deaths per capita is the interesting, relevant statistic. California is actually pretty high here too; it has more gun deaths per capita than Texas, though gun ownership rates are far lower in CA. Anyone know why? My best guess is that the gun ownership rates rely on legal sales, but gun homicide rates don't. So California, because of strict rules, has proportionately more illegal guns (perhaps purchased in lax states, like Texas).
- egoodz 11y agoThat's my thinking - larger amount of illegal sales for use by those involved in gangs/drug game.
- koube 11y agoI'd also like to see statistics on how many of those guns used in crimes are from other states. If there is a successful gun control program but the state is bordered by states with more lax gun control, then that confounds any gun statistics. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/12/us/gun-traffickers-smuggling-state-gun-laws.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/11/12/us/gun-traffic...
- mikeash 11y agoDon't your two points contradict each other? You say that legal gun ownership isn't the main issue, using homicide statistics as the basis, then say that most gun deaths are suicides, and in another comment say that suicide is the real problem. Legal gun restrictions may not affect homicides much (I'm skeptical of this view, but it is an obvious fact that criminals don't always obey the law) but I would think that they would affect suicides a lot.
- marcoperaza 11y agoI don't think a comparison of suicide rates in Western democracies would support that. And regardless, the fact that people kill themselves is no reason to ban guns. With that logic, we should be banning burgers, soda, sweet cars, ice-climbing, and motorcycling. In a free society, individuals are free to harm themselves.
- mikeash 11y agoThe US suicide rate is about 12 per 100,000 per year, the UK's is about 6, Canada's is 10, Germany's is 9, France's is 12, looks like we are on the high end even if it's not totally consistent. As for banning burgers and the rest, that's a totally separate question. One of the major problems with the American gun control debate is that all sides completely fail to separate questions of fact from questions of principle. The question of what effect a particular gun law will have is completely separate (although it may inform) the question of whether enacting that law is the right thing to do. To say that it's better not to certain gun laws even though it would save lives, because the freedom is more important, is perfectly reasonable. But we have to actually figure out the "it would save lives" part first to get to that point in the discussion. If the law doesn't even work then you might as well not bother with the rest.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- codazoda 11y agoI can't back it it with data but I suspect that many of the gun owners in California do not report their gun ownership, contributing to the low number.