2 ms·
If Google switched to anything like that, I'd be tempted to GreaseMonkey it back to how it was. It looks a bit like Bing. Just to start: Not every result has th
by petercooper 17y ago
If Google switched to anything like that, I'd be tempted to GreaseMonkey it back to how it was. It looks a bit like Bing. Just to start: Not every result has the domain showing (unless you mouseover) which makes it hard to filter the crud at first sight and results are spread too far apart. When you do mouseover, the URL is in a realllly bright, hard to read green. I thought fades, pastel colors, and stupid mouseover effects went out in 2008.
I take back what I said about Google not having enough creatives on the other Google story today. At least the engineers have made something that's usable..
- Semiapies 17y agoAgreed. Design is not simply a matter of appearance. Google's design is clear and useful. This Air theme is arty for the sake of being arty, and it's not even particularly attractive.
- mortenjorck 17y agoI don't get the feeling that this design saw much user testing. As you describe, the domain plays an important part in helping mentally filter results and thus doesn't really merit relegation to rollover visibility. What I think would qualify for that is the rest of the URL path. Overall, as nice as it all looks, there are some serious discoverability issues. "Show options" doesn't need to be shown in as much detail as Google has it, but the plus-sign itself isn't enough to go on. The rollover visibility for the other Google products just makes it hard to find them; the header isn't that noisy with them visible. The single gear for settings/sign in is a little better than the lone plus sign, but still, such condensation is extreme, especially for the importance Google places on getting users to use accounts.
- nostrademons 17y agoIt's interesting to read the comments here, because I was involved in the design of a lot of these features, and many of the elements of "Air" have been considered and rejected for exactly the reasons that HN readers point out.
- dandelany 17y agoI agree with everything you've said. Plus, the page is so javascript-heavy, it probably crawls in IE6. It already makes my scrolling a little less smooth. Interface responsiveness and discoverability trump flashiness and visual minimalism. Other nitpicks: the slightly grey (cream?) background is a weird, subtle annoyance, and the lack of any underlined links would definitely get Nielsen's panties in a bunch. One thing I think the (re)designer did get right: The AJAX-loading down arrow at the bottom of the page. I wonder if there's any reason Google hasn't tried something like this over their more traditional pagination model. I'm guessing it has something to do with advertising and/or existing SEO conventions of referring to result ranking by Google page #.
- eagleal 17y agoAgreed. I think this is more a web design than a UI/UX work. Usability here is nearly non existent.