3 ms·
In general: there's an appreciation for basic logic that is necessary. In Curious Wavefunction's field, chemistry (which is something I am, uh, somewhat famili
by dnautics 11y ago
In general: there's an appreciation for basic logic that is necessary.
In Curious Wavefunction's field, chemistry (which is something I am, uh, somewhat familiar with), graph theory could probably be useful, but useful graph theoretic construction for retrosynthetic analysis seems to be persistently elusive since at least E. J. Corey's era.
But sometimes just being able to do math is important. Today I got into a minor dispute with someone who is running a sequencing/diagnostics startup. Their sequencing technique is, reported as of late 2015, getting an 8% error rate for an 8x coverage sequence. Asked him what the error would have been for a 1x coverage, and he couldn't answer. I would think that if you're going to be using sequencing to do diagnostics, being able to rapidly figure out things like this is important.
- wobbleblob 11y agoThe article makes this claim: > "Most top chemists and biomedical researchers have little use for mathematics per se, except in terms of using statistical software or basic calculus. " Now I never ended up working in the field, but I remember my organic chemistry Msc. being fairly math heavy. Solving the Schroedinger equation for a complex molecule or refining a stochastic simulation model involved a bit more than basic calculus. The whole course was more math than lab work. Was this article written by someone who never took an advanced science class, or by a mathematician to whom all the math used in natural sciences is trite and simple?
- dnautics 11y agoI think Curious Wavefunction was a practicing chemist. Nobody really solves schroedinger equations (actually you can't really solve it for anything besides hydrogen) and first-pass "gut" understanding of kinetics is usually good enough to get most things done. As for kinetics: in practice, just do it five times at five temperatures to find the best yield where it goes fast and doesn't degrade. This would be for organic synthesis. Biochemists use kinetics more, one time my boss yelled at her grad students for using 1 uL pipettes because they have poor resolution for kinetic studies, but even so they're not necessary for many studies (for example, for my biochemistry pretty much everything was pushed to the saturating rate and we had linear kinetics).