3 ms·
I don't think they are losing mindshare. Mathematica is simply unparalleled in its features. Any stats showing they are hurt by the closed nature of their softw
by kccqzy 11y ago
I don't think they are losing mindshare. Mathematica is simply unparalleled in its features. Any stats showing they are hurt by the closed nature of their software?
- _delirium 11y agoMindshare is a bit fuzzy, but at least among academics, I do think its closed-ness has made it lose some of its luster in recent years. Mainly because the bigger focus on reproducibility and open code and such has made people feel like it's not quite the "right" way of doing things, especially if you're preparing something for public consumption (vs. private experimentation), compared to e.g. the more community-based and open Python math ecosystem. Ten or fifteen years ago people didn't think about that as much, so people used Mathematica happily. Nowadays of course many people still use Mathematica, but, unless my circle is totally unrepresentative, a good number feel a little more uneasy and maybe slightly guilty doing so, and have at least a desire and vague plans to switch if/when they find time or the alternatives get better.
- blt 11y agoAs a researcher currently working in Matlab, if/when I release code publicly I'll be porting to C++ and writing bindings to other languages. It doesn't feel like I'm really contributing much to the community if I release code that requires thousands of dollars to run.
- exDM69 11y agoGNU Octave is a free/open alternative for Matlab, which is mostly compatible with things built in Matlab. Just make sure your code runs in Octave and you don't have to do any porting. There's no viable alternative to Mathematica, let alone a compatible one. Even for the basic stuff I've used Mathematica (student license) for, basic symbolic integration, differentiation and simplification, I get inferior results from Sympy and Maxima. I haven't tried XCas yet, some say it is better. And this is only talking about the computer algebra capabilities. Mathematica has all sorts of nice tools for doing plots, interactive UIs and other stuff.
- tudorw 11y agoHere's a quick slideshow on Software Sustainability and Reproducible Research in Remote Sensing from Robin Wilson, https://speakerdeck.com/robintw/software-sustainability-and-reproducible-research-in-remote-sensing https://speakerdeck.com/robintw/software-sustainability-and-... he also writes a blog that often discusses the subject in the broader sense http://blog.rtwilson.com/in-praise-of-projecttemplate-for-reproducible-research/ http://blog.rtwilson.com/in-praise-of-projecttemplate-for-re...
- lutusp 11y ago> Any stats showing they are hurt by the closed nature of their software? No reliable statistics, only the conjecture that Sage, sympy and other such environments allow people to produce a significant percentage of the results Mathematica can produce. Mathematica still has a substantial territory of advanced results unmatched by the free environments, but the gap is narrowing as the years pass. I know this -- students are much more likely to acquire Sage or IPython than purchase even the lower-priced student version of Mathematica, simply because they can get the former for free, and there's plenty of high-quality documentation and examples available (example http://arachnoid.com/IPython http://arachnoid.com/IPython). And how many undergraduate courses require the kinds of advanced results that only Mathematica can produce? And given those specific results, in an academic environment how much of a penalty is it that only the result is produced with no explanation or context?