3 ms·
There is a big difference between "I don't believe you were trying to be constructive", (which make assumptions about intent) and "I found your critique to be u
by shkkmo 11y ago
There is a big difference between "I don't believe you were trying to be constructive", (which make assumptions about intent) and "I found your critique to be un-constructive, here's why:"
The former adds nothing to the conversation and is pretty close to being a personal attack, the latter provides feedback and (may) prompt constructive debate about how to provide critique.
- ethanbond 11y agoSure, here's why it's not constructive: not once in the parent comment is an alternative suggested or a question raised. Just a list of things that are "wrong," according to the poster.
- ctvo 11y agoIt's a resume piece and the parent works for a design company. He's not looking to start a discussion on the merits of the design and how to improve it, only his problems with it from a hiring perspective (polish, consistency, lack of research). It feels very constructive to me.
- ethanbond 11y agoThen what separates constructive criticism from just criticism? Parent comment supplied criticism – I'm not arguing that. But s/he did not at all help to reveal a path towards a better outcome. That's what would make it constructive.
- gadflea 11y agoJudgements on motive, while critical for investigations and character analysis, are obviously irrelevant to online tech discussions, famously impervious to baggage, ideology, and petty warble.