7 ms·
Keyboard shortcuts have good discoverability in most applications, because they're listed alongside the drop-down menu options. If you use Edit->Copy a lot, you
by jdietrich 11y ago
Keyboard shortcuts have good discoverability in most applications, because they're listed alongside the drop-down menu options. If you use Edit->Copy a lot, you can see in the menu that there's a keyboard shortcut.
Many of Apple's UI interactions can only be discovered through guesswork or reading the docs. If you open Launchpad often, nothing alerts you to the fact that there's a touchpad gesture for that. Unlabeled icons are rife in iOS and there is no discovery mechanism equivalent to a tooltip.
- shkkmo 11y agoThe lack of discoverability extends to OSX's keyboard shortcuts as well. I completely changed how I work after I discovered 'Command Tab' and 'Command ~'
- christoph 11y agoIt's amazing how buried some of these are. Nothing tops print screen for me - Cmd + shift + 3 for the whole screen or Cmd + shift + 4 for the selection option...
- fallenhitokiri 11y agoMy absolute favorite is cmd + shift + 3 - release - space to take a shot of a single window. Maybe it's the release part between 3 buttons and pressing space, but that shortcut is always wired to use for me.
- Kexoth 11y agoI didn't knew this one, it's awesome, but it's with 4 instead of 3 :)
- dingo_bat 11y agoTo this day, I have not figured out how to switch to another desktop on my Macbook Air using a keyboard shortcut. To be fair, I use it very rarely.
- twoodfin 11y agoControl-Left|Right Arrow.
- dingo_bat 11y agoGotta try it when I bring it out next. Thanks!
- Zarel 11y agoI'm pretty sure the default is Ctrl+Left and Ctrl+Right, but I've customized it so many times I can't be completely sure. OS X actually allows a lot of customization. You assign a keyboard shortcut to any menu item in System Preferences -> Keyboard -> Shortcuts -> App Shortcuts.
- falcolas 11y agoThe discoverability is there, but not in the wild of the OS; it's in the Settings panel. Better yet, it's configurable (and powerful). Settings > Keyboard > Shortcuts > Keyboard Ditto that for the touchpad (including animated examples) Settings > Trackpad > ... Perhaps we as power users are just used to not having to visit these locations?
- shkkmo 11y agoThose are actually precisely where I discovered a bunch of OSX's shortcuts. I think this was around the time I configured the two finger right click to make playing Minecraft without an external mouse feasible.
- Retric 11y agoWindows OS is full of shortcuts that are non obvious ex: Windows + E or even the classic Alt + Tab.
- andrepd 11y agoExactly. GP has a good point, but it's a problem not exclusive to Apple.
- tripzilch 11y ago> If you use Edit->Copy a lot, you can see in the menu that there's a keyboard shortcut. You can. And I do. And given your post, I assume you do too. But did you know that most people don't? I teach people computer skills (a lot of children, ages 8-12, but other ages as well). Only the very clever ones (those we can expect to welcome on HN in a couple of years ;-) ) figure it out by themselves. You'd be surprised of the in-your-face stuff people simply do not read on the screen. I then point it out, but it's about 50/50 whether they'll pick up the habit. And it's the same thing with this interface the author has designed. It's all intuitions about how he uses computers, how people like him use computers, and how the self-selected group of feedback-providers use computers. Nothing about the general public. No research, no tests, no reference to classic UX textbooks and theory. Now if he had stated upfront that those three categories are actually the only intended target audience, then at least he would have acknowledged that this is a possible problem, up-front. Not doing so, it appears he hasn't given much thought to it. So, sorry but what I see is not a user interaction designer, but a graphics designer with a cute hobby. If you think that's harsh, imagine he'd have redesigned the user interface of your car. Would you trust the ideas reading only about mockups and "intuitive" justifications? Wouldn't you think, mm-mm yes nice ideas but until you actually tested them on a focus group they could go anywhere and further effort is pretty much wasted until you do. What if you assume his driving style is rather different from yours?