4 ms·
From a slightly different angle, Lior Pachter focuses on how science is often a pyramid scheme of sorts: https://liorpachter.wordpress.com/2016/01/18/the-heroe
by epistasis 11y ago
From a slightly different angle, Lior Pachter focuses on how science is often a pyramid scheme of sorts:
https://liorpachter.wordpress.com/2016/01/18/the-heroes-of-crispr/ https://liorpachter.wordpress.com/2016/01/18/the-heroes-of-c...
>There is a more cynical view of the PI model, namely that by running large labs PIs are able to benefit from a scientific roulette of their own making. PIs can claim credit for successes while blaming underlings for failures. Even one success can fund numerous failures, and so the wheel spins faster and faster…the PI always wins.
>Lander concludes his perspective by writing that “the [CRISPR] narrative…is a wonderful lesson for a young person contemplating a life in science”. That may be true of the CRISPR narrative, but the lesson of his narrative is that young persons should not count on leaders in their field to recognize their work.
- nextos 11y agoI was about to say the same thing, but Lior's writeup is much more straightforward. I started doing research in formal methods but later moved to computational biology. Half a decade later I'm still surprised by the concepts of PI, last author and lack of blind reviews. How can anyone that does not even understand the main ideas in my works sign it as a major author?
- cowsandmilk 11y agoI frequently have worked with people in Bob Langer's lab, which is an absolutely enormous group. Most of them described it as being a place where virtually any piece of equipment you wanted to use was available to you, but you will have very little supervision. For a scientist who has a crazy idea that doesn't want to be micromanaged, that can be an ideal environment. Those crazy ideas are the most likely to be published in Science or Nature if they work, in which case, having a famous PI like Langer or Church helps a surprising amount. So, yes, being in a huge lab is a bit of a pyramid scheme, and probably gives undue credit to the PIs. But, for the right person, it can be the perfect environment to test your ideas and, with a bit of luck, publish some high profile papers.