3 ms·
Most people are grossly simplifying this discussion. The worst for me still is those who yell "Luddite Fallacy" whenever this discussion comes up. What most pe
by ThomPete 11y ago
Most people are grossly simplifying this discussion. The worst for me still is those who yell "Luddite Fallacy" whenever this discussion comes up.
What most people are missing is that it's not so much automation but rather digitalization which allows for a completely differen kind of automation thats not just mechanical but instead has some kind of intelligence embedded in.
The point is that technology is simulating higher and higher levels of abstraction and thus are replacing not just human physical abilities but also our intellectual ones.
And if you want to understand what that means. Then ask yourself what profession did the horses enter once cars made them obsolete in transportation.
It's also interesting to notice that the last 100 years only new kind of job have emerged and that's computer scientists. Most other jobs today are really just modernized versions of older ones.
The luddite fallacy is in itself a fallacy and everyone who subscribe to that view really should explain exactly what new kind of areas humans will be going into. Surely they should already exist today.
And if you want to claim that new jobs are being replaced when technology takes some away then you really need to explain this graph.
https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-states/ https://plot.ly/~BethS/8/job-growth-by-decade-in-the-united-...
- jacquesm 11y ago> It's also interesting to notice that the last 100 years only new kind of job have emerged and that's computer scientists. I think you're missing a couple there, the number of professions that hold a sizable number of people has absolutely exploded since the 1950's. Ranging from all the jobs that were created by the electronics revolution, the transportation revolution, all the new media and the IT revolution is much more than just 'computer scientists'. How do I know this? Because at some point I was responsible for maintaining a table that mirrored the Dutch bureau of statistics annual table with the names of all the professions. The number of new professions that were recognized each year was absolutely staggering, but if you went back over time you could see an inflection point somewhere just after world-war II.
- ThomPete 11y agoWhich jobs are you talking about? I am talking about fundamentally new types of jobs.
- jacquesm 11y agoIf you want to be pedantic, even computer scientists were around 100 years ago (Ada Lovelace, for one). Really, if you want to discount all the fields I've named on principle because to you those jobs are not 'fundamentally new types' then computer programmer also doesn't qualify as a fundamentally new type of job. Assembly line worker wasn't a profession in 1912 either, it only became one in 1913 when the assembly line was invented. Classes of professions have not been invented since about 500 years ago, typically the classes of professions that are recognized haven't changed much at all, and yet, you'd be hard pressed to find 'tour-operator', 'social media strategist', 'geneticist', 'nuclear reactor operator' and so on in a list of jobs from the early 1900's. And by that reasoning 'computer scientist' is just a sub-class of scientist, actually one of the oldest professions we have. 'Fundamentally' is a cheat, there are no new 'types' of jobs, there are only jobs that did not exist before and there are jobs that nobody holds anymore.
- ThomPete 11y agoI don't see how that is pedantic at all. Bringing up Lovelace however is quite pedantic and I think you know that very well. Assembly line worker did not require any new skills. Instead it required a subset af the previous skills people had whether welders, blacksmiths, carpenters, painters etc. So you haven't really pointed to any new jobs and no fundamentally new type of jobs isn't a cheat. Furthermore I am not really sure what you are trying to prove. Even if I had missed a few (which I haven't) it wouldn't change the facts.
- jacquesm 11y agoI'll supply astronaut instead and see you argue around how that really is just another form of 'traveler'.