3 ms·
> Plus my understanding is that these ledgers do not scale. Each transaction takes a lot of computing power. This is a particularly gross distortion of reality
by CyberDildonics 11y ago
> Plus my understanding is that these ledgers do not scale. Each transaction takes a lot of computing power.
This is a particularly gross distortion of reality by people who for whatever reason want people to believe cryptographic currencies won't scale.
In the infancy of a currency, when there aren't many transactions, the mining power amortized over each transaction will be much more than when many transactions are happening. Each transaction doesn't take mining power, the number of transactions and mining are completely decoupled.
- markeroon 11y agoWell, the above poster is half right. Blockchains don't scale as well as, say, a distributed database. It's not due to computational constraints, it's the amount of data handled by every node. Bitcoin can currently handle about 2 transactions per second.
- CyberDildonics 11y ago> Bitcoin can currently handle about 2 transactions per second. First, this isn't the real number and second 'handle' doesn't describe the situation, which is an artificial limitation built in as an artifact. Whether you are in the camp that believes this will be worked around in bitcoin or not is irrelevant, on a technical level any cryptocurrency can be created that can handle MANY more transactions. Right now you could sync to the blockchain on the bandwidth T-Mobile gives for free while on international roam in 100 countries. So the amount of data handled by every node is not even close to any sort of practical limit. Anyone with Netflix could sync to 50x the number of transactions.
- markeroon 11y agoI agree with the above and you make a fair point, mine still stands though: a decent distributed db could still do substantially better.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoDo better at what? Handle more data? Of course, but computers aren't exactly struggling with handling enough integer math to move a balance from one place to another. That isn't the problem with things like this. The problem is trust, transparency and accountability. The old "A rasberry PI could handle the same amount of transactions" misses the point completely.