5 ms·
Those types of comments are downvoted to hell 99% of the time. I'm actually surprised that thread wasn't.
by minimaxir 11y ago
Those types of comments are downvoted to hell 99% of the time. I'm actually surprised that thread wasn't.
- vecter 11y agoYes, I was surprised they weren't downvoted into oblivion either. edit: as bradfa pointed out, this comment is the exactly the kind of noise we want to avoid. shame on me. I'll leave it as an example of what not to do.
- bradfa 11y agoIs your comment here an example of what you'd like to see less of?
- personjerry 11y agoIsn't this comment the equivalent of an upvote? Or was that the point?
- gus_massa 11y agoI'm more pessimistic and I feel that the noise level is increasing. I have seen recently more and more threads like that. I think that now they are downvoted only the 80% or 90% of the time.
- mercer 11y agoCould it be a time-of-the-year type thing? A certain demographic spending more time inside behind a computer? Or maybe a new HN app that makes it more accessible?
- gus_massa 11y agoSeasonal variation is a possible explanation (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September ). But I'm not sure if that the explanation. There is a nice comment in a thread of a few years ago, that has an ascii-art graph of the quality of the HN comments [1]. The values are made up, but it show that the quality oscillates, and people complain when it's descending. But it will bounce! (I hope.) So, I'm not desperate, but a small rant of another user makes me not feel that I'm the only one that sees a problem. [1] I can't find the original comment. Do someone have it in a bookmark? [2] Lots of karma (or more precisely at least 1) for someone that can make a real graph using some kind of metric to guess the comment quality. (Length is a good proxy. Points need a correction due to the increase in users and karma inflation. Deep learning?) Does the real graph show seasonal variation?