3 ms·
In my mind there's a big difference between, say, driving "traffic" speed (where traffic is moving 10-15 mph faster than the speed limit), and drunk driving or
by nostrademons 17y ago
In my mind there's a big difference between, say, driving "traffic" speed (where traffic is moving 10-15 mph faster than the speed limit), and drunk driving or failing to stop at a red light. The former actually improves safety - most accidents are caused by speed differences between vehicles, not absolute speed. The latter is a good way to kill someone or get killed.
And in my experience most traffic enforcement seems to be against the latter kind of behavior. (Well, except the cops who sit at the bottom of a hill where the speed limit drops from 35 to 25, because their town needs revenue.) I've never known someone to get pulled over for speeding when they're driving traffic speed on a highway, even if there's a cop right behind them. I think people should and do get pulled over if they're weaving or blindly zooming through red lights.
Isn't it interesting that something as clear cut as traffic laws could spawn such a debate? Pretty good evidence, IMHO, that laws are not clear-cut and there's room for judgment calls in a lot of them.
- Silhouette 17y agoI agree with almost everything you write there, except that unfortunately here in the UK enforcement doesn't work like that. Right now, cameras are the preferred way to do a lot of things (speed, red lights, bus lanes), and databases get a lot more (uninsured, not paid the right tax at the right time, etc.). Meanwhile, the budget for traffic police officers who are out on patrol and can do something about the really serious problems has been slashed, sometimes by a factor of three or more, in most areas. During debates with local councillors here, two views come up repeatedly: drivers think that the bad driving is getting more frequent and more offensive, and the remaining traffic police officers are frustrated that they can't do much about it because they're already at full stretch, so even some major roads simply don't get patrolled at all. > Pretty good evidence, IMHO, that laws are not clear-cut and there's room for judgment calls in a lot of them. The unfortunate thing, IMHO, is that so many of these laws are clear-cut. It would be much better, again IMHO, if there were fewer prosecutions, but those that took place went to a real court where a proper judgement could be made, taking into account all the facts of the specific case.