3 ms·
Errr, "this freedom is limited to Congress not making laws restricting speech" was true prior to the passage of the 14th Amendment. That enforces it on the sta
by hga 17y ago
Errr, "this freedom is limited to Congress not making laws restricting speech" was true prior to the passage of the 14th Amendment. That enforces it on the states, and Morse v. Frederick (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bong_Hits_for_Jesus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bong_Hits_for_Jesus) was based on previous "school speech" jurisprudence. Schools are a special place and special restrictions are allowed in them, but certainly not total bans on political speech.
- jhancock 17y agoSorry if I muddied the debate by bringing in other cases. I was attempting to contrast the decision which perhaps was not necessary. The decision against McCain-Feingold was strictly a 1st amendment one and the 14th does not effect the decision, at least not in what I've read about the ruling.
- hga 17y agoActually the 14th comes into play, not WRT McCain-Feingold but in that the Supremes explicitly reversed Austin v. Michigan Chamber of Commerce, which was about a state law. I've read that 28 or so states have laws which will come under wilting scrutiny now.