3 ms·
That's one of the characteristics of evolution of any sort... things don't really happen for this reason or that reason, they happen because of all the reasons
by jerf 11y ago
That's one of the characteristics of evolution of any sort... things don't really happen for this reason or that reason, they happen because of all the reasons all together sort of jostling around and interacting with each other and the solutions and the problems created by those solutions and so on. Even when on occasion one particular change can be pinned to a particular reason, that's the exception rather than the rule and it still is a participant in the jostling.
(This is elaboration on the point, not disagreement.)
- dkrich 11y agoSomewhat off-topic, but this is basically the idea behind "exaptation." Something develops through evolution for one reason, but is found to be superior for a different reason. For example, it is widely believed that feathers evolved purely for warmth, however their structure enabled certain animals to fly.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoI saw on TV last night a throw-away line from a teacher in a drama [1] about "survival of the fittest", and how only the strongest genes survive. I just cringed. I realize that this is how people conventionally think about it, and on the surface it's only subtly different from the real explanation, but the result is that it makes you think about the evolutionary process in a fundamentally incorrect way. I think this is a big part of why people fail to understand how emergent systems pop up all over the place. It leads to the mistaken idea that, for example, being able to design a new economy is just an engineering problem, and we can just paste together what seems to work with our own bright ideas, and get something functional out the other end. [1] Freaks and Geeks
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoIsn't the subtle difference only hanging on the 'survival' word? The best suited genes for the situation get expressed. The fact that other genes are lurking around waiting for their opportunity, doesn't deny the point of the dialog.
- pas 11y agoWell, that too, but the most important thing is the cost to carry a particular adaptation/mutation. If it's low enough, then it won't get thrown out by the pressure of natural selection. If it's beneficial, then it'll get selected for (so it'll spread in the population). That's one way how seemingly uninteresting adaptations have spread, they got lucky and coincided with a useful mutation. So evolution is an optimization process. On a constantly changing landscape.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoAlso that the fitness function applies to the system as a whole. So a trait that's just amazing at something, but carries a large cost, may not be able to survive. I guess that's kinda what you said, just phrased differently. And this is getting away from the central point, but there's also much debate (at least at the level I'm reading; maybe it's solved by now for those in the field) about how traits can support a community at the expense of the individual - like with old humans losing the ability to procreate.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoOk I've always wondered if maybe our old-age feebleness was adaptive! It means the old folks sit around the fire with the young folks, and teach. Once social groups began, that could really boost a community at the cost of a declining agility in old age.
- jacquesm 11y agoFeebleness in old age is simply run down machinery, otherwise there would be no old age, we'd feel the same all our lives long until we died of some kind of accident or ritual murder of those that outlived their welcome.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoTrue. Yet other mammals have different clocks; other creatures seem to have no clock at all. So our clock is set by genetics. Why at this rate? That's the idea I was getting at.
- tamana 11y agoPeople don't pay attention to the words right in front of their faces. FITness is not the same as STRENGTH.