4 ms·
> The EETPU dealt with the problem, other Unions, the NUM (National Union of Mineworkers) did not. It was their aggressive confrontational policies that wrecked
by sangnoir 11y ago
> The EETPU dealt with the problem, other Unions, the NUM (National Union of Mineworkers) did not. It was their aggressive confrontational policies that wrecked worker solidarity in private industry.
I'm not English, but from my (lefty, somewhat uninformed) point of view - wasn't it Maggie Thatcher who "wrecked worker solidarity in private industry"? Or at least wasn't the downfall of unions around her time?
Aside: I have a colleague from Liverpool, let's just say he wasn't distraught upon learning the news of her passing.
- arethuza 11y agoDominic Sandbrook in his history of the 1970s, Seasons in the Sun, makes the point that the "every man for himself" attitude of some of the unions in the 1970s actually had more in common with Thatcherism than the old-school Labour types who gave us the NHS.
- Wildgoose 11y agoNotable (Labour Party) left-winger Barbara Castle tried to address the problem of excessive Union militancy with a proposal "In Place of Strife" as early as 1969. It failed and the problems only got worse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Place_of_Strife https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_Place_of_Strife So, instead of the Labour Party dealing with the problem it ended up being Thatcher's Conservative Party. Let's just say, one extreme to the other.
- cmdkeen 11y agoFolk mythology isn't always based on underlying facts. Thatcher wasn't perfect but the decline in British manufacturing and mining had been happening long before - the graph of employment in British manufacturing is essentially a 45 degree downward slope from 1961 going back to the same (absolute) number of people in 1991 as were in employed in 1891. In the same way Thatcher didn't shut the largest number of pits. Britain was the "sick man of Europe" during the 70s, we got bailed out by the IMF in 1976 - unions gave us the Winter of Discontent. Far too many confrontational unions protected Spanish Practices and demanded unjustifiable pay increases which bankrupted companies - not to mention earned a dire reputation for quality. I see a lot more "worker solidarity" in things like German work councils than 70s British trade unions, they didn't seem to have any concept of creating a sustainable business and ultimately wanted everything nationalised in order to separate pay from profits.