9 ms·
Why Violins Have F-Holes
- test1235 11y agoI wonder why guitars don't have f-holes as well?
- 20after4 11y agosome do: https://www.google.com/search?q=guitar+f-holes&safe=off&source=lnms&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=guitar+f-holes&safe=off&sour...
- dsego 11y agoArchtop guitars usually do.
- spdionis 11y agoSemi-acoustic guitars always do.
- oDot 11y agoThe Gibson ES-335 has f-holes. These guitars were famously used by BB King, his own named Lucille. When Gibson made a signature model he asked to remove the f-holes to reduce feedback: > The most noticeable differences between the Lucille and the Gibson ES-355TD-SV on which it is based are the "Lucille" script on the headstock, the maple neck, and the lack of F-holes on the top. King requested that, to reduce feedback, there be no F-holes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucille_%28guitar%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucille_%28guitar%29 There's a very good song by him talking about Lucille: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Y8QxOjuYHg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Y8QxOjuYHg
- beat 11y agoThe ES335 is a "semi-hollow", with a solid block of wood running from the neck to the bridge.
- falcolas 11y agoSome do, but the bodies of guitars (with the exception of archtops) are built differently from violins. Namely, the top and bottom of a violin are carved (the thickness ranges between 3 and 8mm), whereas the guitar has a mostly uniform thin (0.5 - 1mm) sheet of hardwood with support bars. One of the big reasons for the different style of top is that a bowed violin string produces much stronger vibrations than a plucked guitar string, so the body of a guitar must amplify the sound much more than the body of a violin.
- beat 11y agoArchtop guitars with carved tops usually do. Flat-top acoustic guitars have a complex bracing system that would get in the way of F-holes (nylon string guitars are usually fan-braced, and steel string guitars, with more tension, are X-braced).
- larrym 11y agoTotally on the ball.
- peletiah 11y agoThere's a secret geometry hidden in this shape as well: http://imgur.com/uEsdUke http://imgur.com/uEsdUke
- baxter001 11y agoSeems a touch to aesthetically pleasing to be truly optimal, given they have a partial fitness function in terms of radiated power I wonder what a GA would come up with.
- jacquesm 11y agoThere's your chance to out-run Stradivarius. The thing you're going to have to deal with next is how your improvement weighs in against playing an instrument for a few hundred years. You might be able to work this out by comparing a brand new regular violin with your improved model in a series of double blind tests for preference and then do the same thing every couple of years afterwards to see if there is a diverging trend. One possible problem here is that the appreciation for classical music is not exactly on the rise and really high quality violins have limited applicability elsewhere. It's a matter of time before there will be more quality violins than violinists (and most of them will live in China where there is a fairly large continent of classical performers, and their numbers are actually on the rise).
- kelvin0 11y agoI always thought violin craftsmen simply liked math and integration :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methods_of_contour_integration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methods_of_contour_integration
- jacquesm 11y agoThe only comment there makes a very good point, the c shape has a 'tab' of wood and if that runs along the grain of the top then it can easily break off, the f shape does not have that property. So maybe what started out as a mechanical improvement actually turned out to work better because the vibrations are divided more evenly to the sides of the hole.
- analog31 11y agoIn addition, the corners at the top and bottom of the C are stress risers, encouraging the propagation of cracks from those points. There's nowhere for a crack to start on an f-hole. I'm sure the old luthiers were not only experimenting with tone quality, but also with repair issues.
- jacquesm 11y agoYes, absolutely. And if that lesson had been kept around then we might have lost fewer early passenger aircraft.
- jerf 11y agoThat's one of the characteristics of evolution of any sort... things don't really happen for this reason or that reason, they happen because of all the reasons all together sort of jostling around and interacting with each other and the solutions and the problems created by those solutions and so on. Even when on occasion one particular change can be pinned to a particular reason, that's the exception rather than the rule and it still is a participant in the jostling. (This is elaboration on the point, not disagreement.)
- dkrich 11y agoSomewhat off-topic, but this is basically the idea behind "exaptation." Something develops through evolution for one reason, but is found to be superior for a different reason. For example, it is widely believed that feathers evolved purely for warmth, however their structure enabled certain animals to fly.
- 11y ago
- jhallenworld 11y agoWell can we simulate a violin? If so, it seems we could run an optimization algorithm (genetic algorithm, simulated annealing, etc.) to see if the evolution could be continued. Analogous to machine evolved antenna designs (where NEC is the simulator). It's interesting that pre-electronic instrument design was pretty much all about increasing loudness.
- analog31 11y agoI play double bass, and in Chuck Traeger's book on bass repair, he is pretty blunt: "You get paid to be heard." Loudness is definitely a quality factor with a direct influence on price. Instruments with a sweet tone quality, but lacking in volume, are a tough sell, and will often be modified to bring out more sound. With the exception of a few museum pieces, the Strads have all been modified over the years to make them louder, with longer necks and shorter ribs. I suspect the cello edged out the viola da gamba because of volume.
- jhallenworld 11y agoOh, I have to promote my friend Noah's human powered electronic instrument, the "Electric Eel". It's no so easy to have sufficient loudness with even with electronics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8MUgwiZULw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8MUgwiZULw It uses re-purposed printer carriage with stepper motor to generate electricity. With very low latency, the pulse of power boots a synthesizer and powers the audio amp.
- analog31 11y agoLooks like someone sprung a leek.
- mjt0229 11y ago+1 for a Chuck Traeger reference on HN. I'm also a double bassist. Agreed about instrument modifications. It's common in the bass world for a big-sounding instrument to be described as a "cannon". That doesn't speak much for having a singing tone! Maybe in the world of violins and cellos that's more important, though.
- jabv 11y agoI studied cello performance at my university and delved into the world of instrument design when searching for my current cello with its low-five-digit price tag. It is a pretty cool blend of art and science. Folks on HN might like to check out the work of Joseph Curtin, a MacArthur grant recipient from my hometown. He publishes acoustic research and makes world-class instruments (i.e. mid-to-high five-digit prices). http://josephcurtinstudios.com/ http://josephcurtinstudios.com/
- beat 11y agoThis article is fundamentally wrong. The holes in acoustic string instruments are not there to "allow sound to escape". Sound radiates in all directions from the surface of the instrument, although the frequency balance may change from point to point. Consider drums, for example. A drum may be completely sealed, yet still work and still make sound. The purpose of soundholes is tuning the resonant frequency of the acoustic chamber. Google Helmholtz resonators for the theory and math if you like. The area and depth of the port alters the resonant frequency, which is largely a function of volume. Acoustic guitars usually have large, circular holes. When recording acoustic guitars, you should never point the microphone at the soundhole! You'll get a dull, woofy, severely unbalanced sound. There are many mic techniques to deal with the frequency issues, but the most common is a microphone along the neck, aimed backward at the neck/body joint. That wouldn't work if the sound just escaped from the soundhole, as the article implies.
- CarVac 11y agoI don't think it's entirely wrong, at least for violin-family instruments. If I put my hand near the f-holes on my cello while I play, I can feel a shocking amount of airflow in and out of the body. The sound emitted by the holes is indeed unbalanced because that's dominated by the resonant frequency of the instrument, but that's a large part of what gives the instrument such acoustic power. ... Additionally, it does make sense that the sound is more efficiently emitted by narrow holes with lots of edge area: it's like the skin effect in electrical conductors at high frequencies, where most of the current flows near the surface of wires, rather than in the bulk.
- beat 11y agoThe air is flowing because it's a tuned resonator, not because it's making sound. That's how the tuning port works. Sound does come out of the hole, but only incidentally. Its value is tuning the chamber, not releasing the sound. The sound would be radiated regardless, conservation of energy and all that. I think the F shape has a lot more to do with limiting mechanical stress points for cracking. A round hole with the same area as the f-holes would weaken the top and create changes in how the soundboard vibrates. It's different on a flat-top acoustic guitar, where bracing rather than carving governs the strength of the top, and bracing also limits the valid locations for soundholes.
- scarecrowbob 11y agoI was reading a long series of articles by a maker of fine violins, and he pointed out that what we are looking at is not a pair of holes, but the two edges of a single resonating area on an instrument which has been decoupled from the instrument on two sides. I found that a very helpful when understanding the design of these instruments.
- oxryly1 11y agoWithout reading the article: "because violins sound better with f-holes than without." I'm fun at parties.
- analog31 11y agoThere's one more factor to consider: The f-hole determines the shape of the belly itself, and the division of the belly into smaller sections by the bridge, soundpost, and bassbar, is thought to contribute to the tone of the instrument. No major piece of a violin serves just one purpose, and all of the pieces interact. What a glorious mess.
- Outdoorsman 11y ago>No major piece of a violin serves just one purpose, and all of the pieces interact.< Precisely...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 11y agoAlso imitated on the classic Gibson ES-335 ("Electro Spanish") semi-hollow-body electric guitar. (In all likelihood just for styling.)
- Roodgorf 11y agoAren't f-holes a common style choice for electric hollow-bodies in general? Maybe they're all just copying Gibson's example as well, but I can't remember the last time I saw one that had any other shaped sound holes.