12 ms·
We lost religion because the morals and beliefs it was pushing seemed ridiculous. In that we threw the baby out with the bathwater. The community and purpose
by colechristensen 11y ago
We lost religion because the morals and beliefs it was pushing seemed ridiculous. In that we threw the baby out with the bathwater. The community and purpose went out and didn't get replaced.
Some people didn't lose religion, but replaced it with something with equal devotion. You can see many of the same behaviors (including the negative ones) with people and their zealous appreciation for political parties, sports teams, social justice, environmental causes, etc. The same things that were wrong about religion were just as wrong here, but people struggle to see the real problems and replace the void properly with positive things.
- humanrebar 11y ago> ...but people struggle to see the real problems and replace the void properly with positive things. I'm not sure how you do that without some sort of "religion" (loosely defined to encompass environmentalism, scientism, salvation-through-politics, hedonism, etc.).
- Spooky23 11y agoIt is more than that. Religion is the canary in the coal mine -- it's an example of a broad-based activity with longitudinal appeal. Now it's easy to fill every minute with niche activity, like futzing around on HN. Our ability to communicate globally with friends and strangers has kneecapped our local communications (who knows a neighbor anymore). So we're suspicious of neighbors and are intimate with strangers. It's cool and amazing, but it has significant implications.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> We lost religion because the morals and beliefs it was pushing seemed ridiculous. While this is true to an extent, I wonder how much it was because the morals and beliefs pushed by religion seemed ridiculous compared to morals and beliefs promoted by the entertainment industry. You know, the the 'do whatever, fuck whoever', focusing just on the positive side and ignoring the negative side - painting the picture that in the worst case, you'll be a famous person (celebrity dramas).