3 ms·
Absolutely. This was dumb, and quite frankly a cynical bread-and-circus idea in the first place. There was never any meaningful scientific justification for t
by ajross 17y ago
Absolutely. This was dumb, and quite frankly a cynical bread-and-circus idea in the first place. There was never any meaningful scientific justification for the project (nor the Mars one that was announced simultaneously).
Although the grandparent post is right: relative to other wastes in our government (the Iraq war being by far the biggest discretionary one), this is small potatoes. But $8B is $8B, and it means it doesn't have to be cut elsewhere.
- sailormoon 17y agoquite frankly a cynical bread-and-circus idea That may well be the truth. But at least it's a circus founded on science and engineering. The Chinese will be on the moon in a decade minimum, two maximum. When you're sitting at home with the rest of the world watching a large chinese flag being placed on the moon in hi-def colour, what thoughts do you think will be going through your head? I bet it's not "boy, I'm glad we didn't waste that $8 billion back in the day!".
- briansmith 17y agoYou are implying that the Chinese going to the moon will harm us. How so? Maybe instead of thinking "Damn, there's a Chinese person on the moon!" we should think "Wow, there's a person on the moon!" and then maybe "But why?"
- sailormoon 17y agoI didn't mean to come across like that. I will be delighted to see a Chinese person on the moon. I will be delighted to see anyone on the moon. What will dismay me is the short-term thinking that led us to squander our lead in the first place. And as for "why" .. why do anything? "Because it's there".
- DannoHung 17y agoGAH, why does Hacker News cut off replies at certain points? This is a response to the child of this post talking about Chinese moon missions: My thoughts will entirely depend on just what space development we have done in the intervening years. If some company is beginning an asteroid surveying mission or there is an orbital construction platform, I'm not going to give two damns about what the Chinese are doing with flags. Good for them! If we are going to spend money on space we should stop thinking in terms of spectacle.
- sailormoon 17y agoHere's a trick: if you click the direct link to the post, you can reply there without any cutoffs :D And hey, I agree. If Team USA is building orbital platforms and doing asteroid surveys by then, then I will be utterly delighted. If, however, because of our lack of long-term vision and misplaced priorities, the space exploration arena comes to be utterly dominated by India, Russia, China, the EU and Japan, then I think I will be justified in lamenting the failings of leadership in my own country I perceive today. Well, I'm not even American actually (though I have family who are), but y'know, I feel a sort of inter-westerner kinship ...