3 ms·
Those aren't the skills necessary to play a modern open-world game such as Skyrim successfully, those are the skills necessary for a human to play, for fun, wit
by jodrellblank 11y ago
Those aren't the skills necessary to play a modern open-world game such as Skyrim successfully, those are the skills necessary for a human to play, for fun, without cheating.
Another way to play "successfully" is to edit memory locations and spoof protocol packets, set inventory=full, score=MAX_SCORE and level position= $LAST_LEVEL and declare yourself the winner.
Unless and until we can encode 'play by our rules, uphold our values' into an AI - they won't. A real-world fear is that we build AI without encoding 'care about human life, self-determination, bodily integrity, freedom of thought and movement, environmental surroundings, etc.' into it right from the start.
- soared 11y agoI understand you're saying that an AI wouldn't limit itself to following the rules (even if arbitrary), but then it isn't really "playing." So yeah, I agree that the fear is an AI won't "play" the game of life, because it might not abide by our seemingly arbitrary rules. What about a rule that says "follow the rules."
- p1mrx 11y agoA game-playing AI could trivially be restricted to the same inputs as a human: send button events, but don't write directly to memory. If it actually figured out how to execute arbitrary code via button presses (humans have done this in Super Mario World), then we should patch the bug and restart the experiment. Of course, an AI gaining control over the real world is a different matter, because in that case it may be too late to restart the experiment.