4 ms·
Concealing the Calculus of Higher Education
- DamnYuppie 11y agoI am not sure I agree with the title. The institutions alluded to in the article are not "hiding" their data. They simply are declining to provide access to it to an aggregator which would allow potential students to more easily compare the costs across multiple institutions. They can still get that data by going directly to the institutions site. Also the comparisons to airlines in the article, in my opinion, is flawed. I compare airline tickets based on cost, schedule, number of connections, and frequent flier affiliation. Plane tickets are reasonably interchangeable based upon any of the above factors. Yet going to a college is a far bigger decision and the decision points are not quite as easily parsed and quantified as purchasing an airline ticket. The consequences of the decisions are not of equal magnitude.
- baldfat 11y agoA big reason is many college's cost DEPENDS on your family's income. So if you look at Stanford it cost $65,000, but if your family makes less then $125,000 it is actually free. http://thinkprogress.org/education/2015/04/02/3642085/stanford-free-tuition/ http://thinkprogress.org/education/2015/04/02/3642085/stanfo... If the family makes less then $65,000 you don't even need to get any sort of financial aid.
- DamnYuppie 11y agoThat still, to me, seems like a thing that could be accounted for by an aggregator. They stated they were willing to work with the institutions I don't see why they can't have specific rules per institution that aligned with their policies.
- baldfat 11y agoI quit my job as a librarian at a small liberal arts college because I felt that the age of private colleges was going away. In the 8 years I have been gone the school has lost almost 50% of the student body and Community Colleges have multiplied. Colleges are scared they won't survive the next next 20 years.
- cinquemb 11y agoIvy league schools and their kindred also seem to be aware that they are inherently in the race to the bottom that "higher education" has become and feel threatened, if they didn't, they wouldn't feel the need to go to such lengths. I wouldn't consider obfuscation in the interest of propagating information for those schools that supposedly want to help students make educated decisions in a reasonable/technically possible manor, unless they need "higher education" before they can decide such things from such basis. Also, ECMC Group keeping the lights on for College Abacus is like putting a band-aid over stab wound. Although, as long as young kids keep buying into the racket because they are told by their elders who paid an order of magnitude less for their "education" or for their “so much more than that” and reinforced by those around them that they need $x for $y (whether academia can only provide $x and if $x is the only way to do $y or not is irrelevant), the show will go on.
- taurath 11y agoAnd those who DID end up paying that order of magnitude more for their education will always enforce that others had to also. Those with more formal education nearly always prefer more educated colleagues regardless of whether its necessary or even helpful for the job at hand.
- baking 11y agoAnother possible reason is that the college's calculators, while required by the federal government, are not terribly accurate. In fact, they are pretty much useless. A comparison would only show which calculators were out of whack the most, which is not really helpful for students looking for cheaper colleges.
- jimrandomh 11y agoThis isn't mysterious. The easier it is to compare prices between colleges, the larger a factor those prices will be in prospective students' decisions. That creates downward pressure on tuition, which means the schools will get less money. So they oppose the creation of tools that make price comparison easier, using any excuses available.
- jkot 11y agoRising cost is fueled by student loans. Problem could be easily avoided, if there would be upper limit on state guaranteed loans, perhaps $50,000?
- Someone1234 11y agoSo now poor students cannot attend top end schools, or expensive courses (law, medicine, engineering, etc), but richer ones can. I completely agree that something has to be done to limit the rise in tuition costs; I personally think greater transparency requirements (e.g. the student has to know how much study will cost before they can be accepted, a system that compares all US colleges for a specific course, etc). I don't honestly think students REALLY grasp how much college is going to be costing them and what the payback period. How can someone spending $40K on an English Lit major really think it is going to pay for itself? They must not have looked at the specifics or figured out the repay period.