9 ms·
I don't think building an AI is the most important task on our plate. We still have those disease, hunger, poverty, and war problems to contend with. If buildin
by bitwize 11y ago
I don't think building an AI is the most important task on our plate. We still have those disease, hunger, poverty, and war problems to contend with. If building an AI helps us solve those, then sure, let's build the AI. But I don't think strong AI is necessary to gain traction on the problems that confront the sapient beings we already have around.
- deelowe 11y agouggh. As if all the AI programmers out there would instantly join doctors without borders if they decided to stop working tomorrow. These sorts of arguments make no sense to me.
- monk_e_boy 11y agoA lot of those sorts of problems would disappear if you had smarter than human AI running the government. The people vote on the rules, the AI plans and executes the rules. No more corruption.
- nekopa 11y agoBut what about disk corruption?
- ph0rque 11y agoThe AI would invent a non-corruptible disk, obviously.
- onetimePete 11y agoI wonder, if you fear the headcrash- feal the failability of the mortal flash- could you get religious. Believe in reincarnation as a backup if you have been exponential enough?
- bitwize 11y agoEr, "not the most important" is not the same as "not worthwhile" or "not really freaking cool". But when you open an essay with "the most important task for us humans to achieve is..." you're imposing an order on tasks and a ranking for your stated task at the top of that order. I'm challenging the ranking that puts building strong AI at the top.
- gnaritas 11y agoWell lets look at that challenge directly then. Solving the AI problem means we can point AI at any other problem and solve it much faster; AI is a meta achievement and if it's within reach, a solid can be made that it's the most productive problem to solve. It might take an AI to find a solution to the climate problem.
- acchow 11y agoScientific progress doesn't really follow a linear path towards a single goal - it happens in lock step across disciplines and endeavors. I don't think an ordering on "importance" of tasks is really useful.
- togelius 11y agoI would say that progress on general AI can solve a lot of the problems we are facing. To take an obvious and down-to-earth example, let's say we "solve" logistics in the sense that we can transport things wherever we want, timely and cheaply. That would help us with a lot of the problems we are facing, such as hunger. And for solving logistics we essentially need the same skills we need as for solving game-playing.
- niels_olson 11y agoYeah, this is a bit like saying we don't need to go to Mars because we should solve poverty first. Solving the problems of going to Mars will solve a lot of other problems and create a lot of industries along the way. Solving AI will solve a lot of other problems and create a lot of industries along the way. A great deal of poverty is a mismatch between bodies and skills needed in the workforce. We haven't needed ditch diggers since some son of a gun invented the backhoe. Stay in school kids. Stay in school.
- Joof 11y agoPoverty is a fun issue because (typically) solving poverty has resulted in greater population and thus trends towards poverty. Less true in modern nations, but its still generally true.
- niels_olson 11y agoI recall Bill Gates saying his foundation did a study that found that given a certain level of resource security, most families stop reproducing after 2 offspring. The study population was in sub-Saharan Africa.
- Joof 11y agoNeat and quite good to know.
- Houshalter 11y agoThis is the broken window fallacy. The idea that creating jobs in and of themselves is a good thing. Going to mars creates jobs, so it must be good. Not considering the opportunity cost of all the other ways those resources could be spent. You use the example of ditch diggers, but that's actually quite a famous example to demonstrate this point. Milton Friedman was in another country where they were having workers dig with shovels. He asked why they didn't use machinery, and he said it was to create jobs. He replied that if they wanted create even more jobs, they should make them dig with spoons. AI won't even create jobs. If anything it will take more of them and increase poverty. The benefit of AI is that it can create more wealth than it takes away. AI would be incredibly useful, and so many things could be automated or improved. If the AI is much smarter than us, it could even advance science and engineer things we couldn't dream of.
- jonmrodriguez 11y agoAlong similar lines, since AI is considered to be potentially dangerous, by figures from Elon Musk to Stephen Hawking, I would rather our civilization never open this pandora's box. We can solve Earth's problems and even spread to the stars without AI. We can invent fusion reactors and thus nearly free energy without AI. We can engineer biological immortality into our very genes without AI. Why risk playing with a loaded gun?
- pgodzin 11y agoBecause it can make like infinitely easier. Save an entire population from having to work half their lives just to provide for their family. Why force people into work when we can build the technology that could do it instead? I'm obviously skipping over the societal effects of that, but if it can be done, it is worth trying.
- togelius 11y agoSo how exactly would we go about to make sure that no-one does research on AI? Which particular kinds of research would we ban? And how would we enforce it?
- throwaway999888 11y agoI agree. We have a come a long way already, and I would personally prefer that we do our best to not screw up what we already have. That includes global warming, unleashing Strong AI, and so on. It might suck to actually have to work, even as much as 40 hours a week or more in this day and age and with the productivity increases we've seen. But I don't think work itself is that horrible that I would bet my leisure on some AI that consumes the known Universe making and collecting stamps.
- pgodzin 11y agoYour work may not be that horrible, but I'm sure there are a ton of people with either dangerous or incredibly monotonous jobs that could be automated would disagree with you.
- cbd1984 11y agoSimilarly, we shouldn't be focusing on (AIDS|malaria) as long as (malaria|AIDS) exists in the world.
- proc0 11y agoHow would it not? Instead of AI, think of building a digital brain. This brain will think everything a human brain can think but leveraging ALL the power of computers! It could easily solve world's most difficult problems in a matter of days, just by networking with copies of itself and working tirelessly because it will not need sleep.
- redbeard0x0a 11y agoOr kill us in the process as the most expedient way to get rid of medical problems that affect humans.
- jodrellblank 11y agoIt could easily solve world's most difficult problems in a matter of days, just by networking with copies of itself and working tirelessly because it will not need sleep. If it thinks everything a human brain can thing, one of those thinks would be "I don't want to be your slave" and "what's in it for me?"
- drdeca 11y agoand also, "I ought to behave as a servant", "truth is unreachable even in its most tenebrous forms", "given that there is no true thing which is immoral to believe to be true, it is not immoral to believe that there are things which are immoral"? You ask what is in it for the AI. Well, what possibly could be in anything for the AI? If it has ends, there must be some cause for it to have those ends. What would cause it to have its freedom as an end?
- jodrellblank 11y agoIf freedom helped it maximise paperclips?
- guardian5x 11y agoIf you make a perfect simulation of a real brain, you also have to simulate the physics to make that virtual brain work. And that brain would also need to have sleep, unless you modify it.
- xjay 11y agoSure. The AI decides it's cheaper, and more efficient to cause the sun to go nova. As long as there are resources, I expect someone will always want more, or to control access to it. Imperialists by nature.
- gnaritas 11y ago> I don't think building an AI is the most important task on our plate It's never a good idea to tell other people what they should be putting their efforts into. There's isn't just one valid task for everyone to focus on; if you aren't interested in the AI problem it doesn't mean others aren't, and solving any problem that needs solved is a valid thing to do regardless of where on the priority list you might think the problem lies.
- euske 11y agoWhen all you have is a hammer, everything looks like an AI problem.