5 ms·
Not that I have any desire to go back to collared shirts, ties, and dresses, but the author caused me to wonder if it wouldn't do something to dial the "frat ho
by mikestew 11y ago
Not that I have any desire to go back to collared shirts, ties, and dresses, but the author caused me to wonder if it wouldn't do something to dial the "frat house" dial back a notch. Because, gawd, does it get old.
I gather that I'm about the same age as the author. And she's right, there was a time that we worked side-by-side with the wimmin folk and didn't think a thing of it. Hey, it was a brave new world of software, and in that brave new world gender didn't matter anymore. I remember it as a time of software being a good place for women to go because it paid well and it didn't matter as much as other fields if you were "a girl". It worked out well for my Mom around that era.
But I don't know when it changed and why it changed, so I don't have good answers for the current situation. But things have changed for sure.
- anarazel 11y ago> Not that I have any desire to go back to collared shirts, ties, and dresses, but the author caused me to wonder if it wouldn't do something to dial the "frat house" dial back a notch. Because, gawd, does it get old. > I gather that I'm about the same age as the author. Fwiw, and I'm not sure that's much, I'm probably a lot younger and male to boot, and I think the same when visiting the offices of some companies that are popular these days.
- mikestew 11y agoFwiw, and I'm not sure that's much Well, it's worth something to me because I sometimes wonder if it's just me being "the old guy" rather than just having a work ethic that causes me to want to go to work to work, not play foosball (not that I haven't kicked some 20-something ass at the foosball table from time to time during work hours).
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoI'm in my early 30s and wish there was a better middle ground. I feel like there is a dichotomy: work for a highly brogrammer company building a fun product from scratch as a slave laborer, or work for boring XYZ.net as a steady Eddie. I want a personal life but I also want to build something new with respectful people in an inclusive environment. The do-or-die environments of most startups just pushes everyone but the bros out.
- MAGZine 11y agoFull disclosure: work for PlanGrid If you are in the bay area, you might want to take a look at PlanGrid. We have a diverse culture which we're proud of, value work-life balance, and still build cool things that make a difference.
- cballard 11y agoFrom your jobs page: > Unlimited vacation days If a candidate requested a firm six weeks of accrued PTO, would that be granted?
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoMy CO also offers unlimited vacation (though they are careful to say it's actually "untracked vacation"). In my experience you can always try but there's a certain amount of unspoken personal capital that's involved that makes the whole process unnecessarily ambiguous.
- cballard 11y agoYes. If you really care about work/life balance, just offer six or more weeks of real PTO. I internally translate "unlimited vacation" to "as little vacation as possible".
- MAGZine 11y agoIt's something that could be negotiated, I'm sure. Personally, I'm interested in minimum vacation policies instead. The founders do reiterate frequently that 5 weeks is expected.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- matt_wulfeck 11y agoFunny you mention PlanGrid because I grew up doing contruction and considered the company. I remember being much more satisfied with my work back then... A fundemental difference I see is that a project is started and then finished, not started and then kept on life support until V2 can be started. Alas your company is in the city and I prefer the valley.
- kokey 11y agoThere is something about the collared shirts. From my experience, I have seen more women in senior, specialist positions at large multinational enterprises like banks and accounting firms. It's also the only kind of place I've seen black and hijab wearing muslim women in senior roles. Almost never in tech companies run by guys in their 20s.
- js8 11y ago> But I don't know when it changed and why it changed, so I don't have good answers for the current situation. I would love to know the answer too. I suspect that thanks to advances of feminism, there are now more professional careers available for women (such as various management positions) and they prefer those to programming or technology. But this theory is, for some reason, controversial.
- hannele 11y agoImagine how you would feel if, to stay relevant and in-touch with the major decisions at your work, you felt pressure to get involved in things that you have literally no interest in. Going on wine tours, maybe some yoga, trashy soap operas that the office loves to hate. Which isn't to say that people would exclude you from their team if you don't get involved, but you couldn't say that you have the easy camaraderie that most of the team seems to have. You're a little outlier, you're not quite in-step, references fly over your head. And you have to be _so careful_ to be friendly, but not _so_ friendly that your co-workers think you're hitting on them. Occasionally, you miss a decision that happened to be discussed at the cocktail bar over lunch - it was just a spur of the moment thing, forgot to invite you, didn't think you would be interested. You talk about how you would have solved the problem, but it's just not seen as graceful enough to be worth exploring further. Because you weren't involved in making those decisions, your name doesn't come up when being considered for lead positions. You're at a company event, and you think you've escaped someone asking you about your spouse that must work there. Then, someone hands you the trash to take out while they tell a hilarious joke about the only things men are good for. You can't put your finger on any one thing (ok, maybe the trash thing), but when another opportunity comes along in a different field, maybe you take it. You can't say you really enjoy your work anyways.
- malandrew 11y agoThis isn't even a gendered problem. The expected social activities may change depending on your gender (i.e. golf, beer tasting, cycling vs yoga, wine tours and soap operas), but getting into management requires people to be comfortable (warmth, "cuddliness", trust in good faith) with you then confident (trust in your competence) in you. You can't rely on competence alone and move on to roles where your competence matters less than how comfortable people are with you in that role. That's why these activities exist. They serve as a proxy for determining if there is a basis to be comfortable and then actually establishing that comfort with one another. You can't establish warmth from code or architecture. Mentoring yes, but not code or architecture. The requirement for warmth enables politicking. The interesting thing about the culture of projects like the kernel dev mailing list is that there is a strong culture of only caring about "Is the code from this person good?" and dismissing the question "Is this a good person (according to my own personal definition of what a good person is)?"
- Pxtl 11y agoI never know if it's nostalgia or not, but I've often felt the same way - that the younger generation of geeks, thanks to one part 4chan and one part Silicon Valley mercantilism, has gotten a very twisted attitude about nerd gender dynamics that's quite different from the idealists of my youth.
- exstudent2 11y agoI think 4chan and Silicon Valley mercantilism are themselves a symptom of public education's failure in general and towards boys in particular. Boys are struggling in many areas in western society. They happen to be succeeding in tech. It's no wonder they're edgy about letting outsiders manipulate the field. Silicon Valley preaches individual achievement and personal responsibility. No doubt boys often needed those skills to survive an education system designed around them. Feminism often pushes for change at the institutional level, not for individual accountability thus the tension IMO.
- nikdaheratik 11y agoI think your opinion is flawed. You seem to be giving Feminism and Education in general too little credit for their good intentions (which are basically, woman being treated equally as men) and way too much credit for their impact on society. People don't found startups because of Feminism, or something they learned in a classroom, or even from listening to some unicorn founder preaching "personal responsibility". They found it as a way to make money doing something interesting instead of super boring CRUD problems. More than that, your opinion about education seems to not actual support the fact that fewer women are going into Computer Science and related fields than were in the 80s. If it was all down to education/politics, and there's more money now in this field than there was then, why has that ratio gone down? OTOH, if the people making the hiring decisions at startups are choosing to not hire women (consciously or not) and those decisions are trickling into the rest of the midsize companies, then maybe there's something wrong with the hiring process itself.
- exstudent2 11y ago
- jmspring 11y agoEven in the early/mid-90s, working along side women wasn't a big deal. I learned a lot from some very capable senior female engineers while at Netscape. I even got some great advice on how to look at things like "part time work", etc. I think the bro-ness goes along side the "work hard, play hard, be at the office all hours" mentality. I've been to a few different gatherings where startups were pitching (including YC) and tune out anyone who pulls the "we are a family, we are here all hours, we blahblahblah" type thing. Liking your coworkers and developing a desire to hang out socially, etc. should develop organically instead of some "mandatory fun" type work culture.
- jmspring 11y agoI should add, I've talked with Google twice over the years. My favorite interview conversation ever was a woman who was deep in kernel development work, the discussion stretched my knowledge and she taught me a lot over the course of an hour interview.
- jdietrich 11y agoThe two most toxic words in the history of tech - "culture fit". Young, smart hackers came to believe that it is not just acceptable to exclusively hire people who look and act like them, but imperative for the survival of their company. Unconscious discrimination is inevitable when you hire based on nebulous factors of compatibility rather than concrete measures of ability. When a founder hires in this way, they create an immense obstacle to diversity. The company grows on this ethos, creating barriers both direct ("she isn't a good fit") and indirect ("I don't want to work in this frathouse"). Improving diversity in these companies is like steering an oil tanker. In my opinion, we need a new hiring norm that reflects the hacker ethos. We need to abandon the multi-day interview gauntlet and replace it with a fair, blinded work assessment. Classical music has seen a boom in diversity since the introduction of blind auditions and we should follow suit. Everything a developer does can be fairly and accurately assessed through IRC and Git commits.
- malandrew 11y agoTwo things happend: (1) The mini-computer happened. You can't read the part in Clayton Cristensen's "Innovator's Dilemma" that talks about how the industry went from 5" drives to 3.5" drives and not see how many computing dinosaurs disappeared to be replaced by completely new companies founded by outsiders that inherited practically none of the culture of the big traditional tech companies from the days of The Organization Man (or Woman). which lead to... (2) The central locus of the tech industry migrated from Route 128 and MIT, which were the power houses post WWII to Silicon Valley and Stanford. The two had polar opposite cultures. Gone were the cultures of places like DEC and IBM to be replaced with the cultures of HP then Apple. AnnaLee Saxenian's book "Regional Advantage" does a great job of chronicling that shift from Route 128 to Silicon Valley and how East Coast and West Coast tech culture differed. If you look at pretty much every story that talked about tech culture back in the day versus today, they are often as much about Route 128 versus Silicon Valley, but few people are aware that such a big shift happened in tech from the 70s to the 80s. It wasn't just new companies built by the same people from the old companies. They were new companies built by complete outsiders to the old computing industry. At MIT, there was tech on campus and mainstream culture was exposed, thus the companies hired from the mainstream. When the center of tech moved to a couple of buildings across the country nestled among rural orchard communities, the people worked at those companies were not a sample of that community, rural orchard farmers. Instead they were the people who were so deeply involved in engineering AND sufficiently detached from their social structures on the East Coast, that they packed up their bags and moved Westward. Migrations are remarkable for their filtering effect. You can see this just by comparing each coast non-tech culture and west coast non-tech culture. The engineers that ended up in Silicon Valley were qualitatively different in attitude and baggage like all the people that settled in SF during the Summer of Love compared to those that remained in their comfortable rooted East Coast lives. Heck, Apple used to fly a pirate flag in their offices. You would have never seen such a display at companies like IBM, DEC, GE, Philips, etc.