14 ms·
Things I've learned at Google so far
- gritzko 17y agoBlah-blah, Google is so cool, nothing worth reading, actually.
- wensing 17y agoI have a place in my brain that keeps telling me that I could never get hired by Google (not-good-enough), but then the part of my brain that keeps me going replies: "On the Internet, no one knows you're not a Googler."
- hello_moto 17y agoAgreed... it's like judging the whole book when in reality he just finished the "preface" part.
- clistctrl 17y agoI've only met two googlers in real life. One past, one present. Both talk about google like its a great place, but both seem slightly spent/burnt from the place.
- hello_moto 17y agoOh... I was referring to the fact that the author just completed his first month at Google... It's hard to judge a company just in one month especially when some people might spend their first week (or two) doing company orientation.
- dschobel 17y agoAgreed. I don't doubt that it's an amazing place to work, but every job has its honeymoon phase and the author is definitely in that. I'd be eager to hear an honest assessment from him after a year though. There has to be a reason why brilliant and motivated people leave Google, after all.
- nostrademons 17y agoI've been there for just over a year. My reactions are basically the same as his - they were the same when I started, but they've dulled as I got accustomed to it. Still think it's a great place to work. The OMG-everyone's-so-smart factor does fade as you get accustomed to all the proprietary infrastructure and realize that hey, I'm smart too. Eventually, intelligence just doesn't matter all that much. It's like my dad's story about starting at MIT: the first 2 weeks, everybody has their phi-beta-kappa rings on all the time. After a month, they've all disappeared, because you realize that everybody else has one too, and then smarts just aren't an issue afterwards. You also tend to become more overworked as you gain competence. There's far more that we'd like to do than what we can do. Eventually that marveling at "Oh my god we built this" becomes "Oh shit I have to build this", which can be very satisfying, but also is a lot of work.
- bigbang 17y agoFor honest assessments, probably reviews on glassdoor.com would help. Blogs are generally going to be positive, as the person's identity is attached to it. Annonymous reviews, has its own problems ofcourse
- _delirium 17y agoThe people I know who've left have left mainly due to the secrecy this article also talks about: they developed cool algorithms they wanted to publish research papers about, and weren't allowed to.
- btilly 17y agoLet's see. I offered advice on gmail that solves complaints I have heard about it in the past from heavy email users. I described a scene of perpetual chaos that plenty of people would hate. And I gave the piece of information that Google is hiring. Those are three pieces of information that I thought were worthwhile sharing which are definitely not simply "Google is cool".
- mrduncan 17y agoI thought there were some really interesting tidbits in there and I enjoyed reading about the office environment. About the information that they're hiring - has there ever been a time when Google wasn't hiring? (I mean that seriously, not to be snarky.)
- btilly 17y agoAbout a year ago Google had a layoff and stopped hiring. This was personally frustrating, because I got through the interview process in Feb, got approved by the hiring committee, then headcount was not approved. Which put me in a state of indefinite limbo. So I had found a different job by the time they contacted me again in October.
- psranga 17y agoDid you have to interview again in October, or did they just reactivate your previous offer?
- btilly 17y agoI wound up in a very different position from what I'd applied for, so they did a phone interview with my potential manager to decide whether I needed to come in for another on site interview.
- nostrademons 17y agoWoah, I really did squeak in under the wire. I got through the interview process in December and started in January. They actually did an end run around Larry Page and had a quorum of other VPs approve my app, because he was on vacation that week and I had another offer I was pretty close to taking.
- jodrellblank 17y ago* Blah-blah, Google is so cool, nothing worth reading, actually.* Bit like your comment. Hence the downvote. It is interesting that someone from the outside has now joined Google and found a lot that they would like to say, but can't. I've also seen anecdotal evidence that the 20% time is largely ignored and up to the employee to push for, but he comments that it's both used a lot and you are marked on it. I guess that varies with where in Google you work.
- gritzko 17y agoSorry, but I can't lie to you. I heard all that Google campus stories a zillion times, except probably for j-k buttons, which are hinted at the bottom of the GMail page, right? Downvote at will.
- jodrellblank 17y agoYou don't have to lie to me/us and pretend you love the post, but HN doesn't need "blah blah zzzz" anymore than you need "another google campus story".
- jff 17y agoAs my boss likes to say, they have the free meals because they expect you to be there for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
- durin42 17y agoHa! I've visited Mountain View enough to know that it's a ghost town when breakfast is actually being served.
- maryrosecook 17y agoI've never seen the problem with being at work for all three meals, given that breakfast and lunch closely bracket work hours. If you are young and don't have a family, having your employer cook you healthy meals is probably a net time-saver, even if you do work 9am - 7pm.
- argv_empty 17y agoIf you are young and don't have a family, having your employer cook you healthy meals is probably a net time-saver, even if you do work 9am - 7pm. Unfortunately, maintaining that work schedule means I'd have to continue to not have a family.
- potatolicious 17y agoMy father's pushing 60 and still working those hours, in IT. If you're going to be working those hours, you might as well spend it with smart people, get paid well, and have free food while you're at it.
- johnyzee 17y agoI am blown away by some of the stuff Google puts out, I can only imagine what their internal technologies and tools must look like. To me, that more than anything validates their approach to hiring, development and business strategy, of which I would otherwise be very sceptical. I'd never get hired at Google, and rightly so; I look at some of their stuff and know that I could never do that. I used to think (not without some scornful resentment) that they were elitist snobs, but you just can't argue with their results.
- elblanco 17y agoI think that you can. To date, Google really only has one successful product (success meaning "makes money for Google") and that's Ad-sense. Sure it's wildly successful. But if that stopped making money for Google tomorrow (for example, I automatically mentally filter out all advertisements in my search results, how long before everybody does that), what would their revenue and profitability picture look like? In almost every other product area outside of web search and perhaps email, where Google competes against another company, they haven't done well at all -- both in terms of users and in terms of dollars. In other words, Google's first product, designed by a couple of grad students, is the loss leader that drives people to their one and only money making product that supplies 99% (not 30%, or 60% or even 80%, 99%!) of their operating capital.
- johnyzee 17y agoAlthough I mentioned business strategy, by 'blown away' I mostly mean engineering enginuity. But as far as business is concerned, they are still in a good spot, what with basically owning the internet, even though they haven't monetized it much. It is fairly obvious that they care more about engineering solutions, with monetization as an afterthought. This means their solutions are extremely dominant in many fields (maps anyone?) - turning that into revenue at some point seems inevitable.
- elblanco 17y ago> turning that into revenue at some point seems inevitable. A true statement, they at least have the foundational technologies for doing better, but so far all of the profitable business ideas seem to center around advertising (youtube anyone?). I'm just not sure how much further that idea can stretch...do I really want to see advertisements while building my house in Sketchup?
- waivej 17y agoThis article really made me want to go work for Google. Is it possible to get tours and meet real employees?
- btilly 17y agoI have no idea about official tours. I rather doubt it though. It is a work place, not a theme park. However if you happen to know someone there, they have the freedom to meet you on campus and show you around all they like.
- chengas123 17y agoIf you know someone that works there, tell them you might be interested and ask them to take you to lunch. They'll be happy to as we're trying to find more people. The Irvine office just had an open house. It was the first time we've done one and I don't know of any more scheduled, but if anyone's in the area I'd be happy to let you know if we have another in the future. If those aren't options, then just apply anyway. We always take candidates to lunch when they interview. Worst case is you decide it's not for you and you have to turn down an offer, but I've been very happy there.
- jlees 17y agoOfficial tours are only for 'official' visitors (and big parties). There's a program to get students visiting if you're in that boat, otherwise, I'm sure a HN Googler would be happy to host you if you're local. What sort of work would you be interested in - engineering? product management?* anything specific within that you'd want to see? Of course, you do get a nice tour and lunch if you get interviewed :) Edit: Ha. Somewhat appropriately, were you to have a campus tour of Mountain View around about today, and should you visit a bathroom in that time, you'd see a quote from pg's "Maker's Schedule, Manager's Schedule" on the back of the stall door...
- petercooper 17y agoGoogle has amazing people. It is often said that engineers find working at Google a humbling experience. This is absolutely true. It took me less than a day to realize that the guy sitting next to me is clearly much smarter than I am [..] without false modesty I wouldn't be surprised to find that I'm as high as being in the top 0.1% in general intelligence (however that could be measured). This strikes me as a problem, rather than an achievement. Google seems to be jam packed with highly intelligent eggheads, but Google isn't a pure science company - they're trying to work with consumers too. Most of the most successful businessmen and entrepreneurs I know don't come even close to the top 1% of intelligence (and are often even dyslexic) as they need a wider range of faculties like common-sense, charisma, creativity, and "emotional intelligence." Maybe this guy's in the engineering department and Google does hire a lot of creatives, business types, and what not, but their products have a rather sterile edge that makes me think the engineers always win over there..
- jlees 17y agoThe focus is on engineers. Google seems to hire people with exactly the qualities you mention to work directly with the consumers, and leave the hyper-genius engineers where they prefer, away from real people ;) Although there is an element of intelligence and also of having a technical background for many of the consumer-facing roles too.
- neilk 17y agoGoogle believes in data only. Designers are not used to justifying their ideas with data. While no one comes out and says it, the implication is that most of what constitutes the design profession is mere flimflammery. You don't need a designer to tell you what shade of blue to pick when you can just A/B test a few hundred shades. That's why a lot of designers quit.
- petercooper 17y agoCan you imagine if they used those sorts of techniques to refine TV schedules? You'd end up with non stop reality and talent shows. Oh, hang on..
- 17y ago
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago>Cats are different, however. Nothing against cats, but Google is a dog place and cats wouldn't be comfortable. Reminded me of this: http://www.rhymeswithorange.com/2008/09/take-your-cat-to-work-day/ http://www.rhymeswithorange.com/2008/09/take-your-cat-to-wor...
- ThinkWriteMute 17y agoI like Google as a company and I love their products (As much as you can love a tool), but jesus how can he work there and use Blogger? It's such a piece of crap.
- jlees 17y agoit's a Google product. it was quite good in 2001 or thereabouts..
- csomar 17y agoWhat's wrong with Blogger? It does its' job well. What's the point from Blogging? -> Getting the word to the others. and it does it well, so it's not crap.
- fexl 17y agoI like blogger.com. Just yesterday I fired up a blog for my wife's retail clothing store. Now she can do all that stuff herself instead of relying on her custom-programmer husband. :)
- ThinkWriteMute 17y agoIf getting it done was the only objective then why isn't Blogger just a web server that people can FTP self written HTML files to? Blogger has a lot of paper cuts that slowly make it either unbearable to use or unsightly to visit. It takes me 4 refreshes just to comment on a page.
- fexl 17y agoI know what you mean, sometimes things can get a little flaky. I haven't tried the comment feature yet. It is after all a big pile of Javascript with WYSIWYG editors and such. So far I have found the bugs slightly annoying, cute, and avoidable. For my own high-powered purposes I've written a completely custom CMS with fully encrypted and extensible object types based on pure text. But have I written an "object" with a WYSIWYG editor, Labels, Archives, and other stuff built in yet? Heck no. So blogger.com here I come.
- csomar 17y agoIn fact this is enshrined as an official corporate policy - engineers get 20% of their time to do with pretty much as they please, and are judged in part on how they use that time. I found a speech claiming that over half of Google's applications started as a 20% project. >> (I'm surprised that the figure is so low.) I wonder why you are surprised? Actually it's very high. Imagine Google don't offer 20% for its' employees, will their productivity (in their real jobs) increase? Probably not, you won't work 100% of your time, you'll work 70% or 80% in best cases. Google profit from this wasted 20% to turn it into useful mini-applications, that can turn big in the future and the best example is Gmail.
- neilk 17y agoVirtually no Google engineers use their personal time to develop new projects. In most cases, they have crushing responsibilities on their existing projects (that guy who appears to be 2x as smart as you and sits next to you? You are competing with him). Usually, people use the official personal time to take mini-sabbaticals with other projects, or write tools to make their own lives easier (which may have more general use within the company, or beyond.)
- nostrademons 17y ago"Virtually no Google engineers use their personal time to develop new projects." I've tried, without success so far, though I've got a bunch of things in the half-done state that could turn into something useful eventually. It is very hard, kinda like starting up a company while keeping your day job. I've found I had the most success by just trying to get my 80% project out of the way as fast as possible, doing as much as needed to keep my teammates happy, and then banking the remaining time to work on 20% projects. It's best used in chunks of a week or so, so that you can actually finish a lot and have something concrete that can sit and wait for your next big chunk of time.
- spicyj 17y agoI thought he was saying that he thought it should be higher than half.
- 17y ago
- neilk 17y agoHi there. I was a Noogler in 2005 or so, but it sounds like things haven't changed much, at least on that side. Regarding the stuff you're not supposed to talk about, there are three stages: 1. Amazement at how it all works; wanting to go run and tell all your friends. 2. Fear that talking about Google's advantages would undermine the company (or your position in it) 3. Recognition that nobody would believe you anyway. By the time you've reached (3) you've come to believe that Google is years ahead of anyone else; you've transferred all loyalties to the company; you accept the idea that you're in an elite of humanity. The reality is that while Googlers are very smart, and sometimes not even narrow, a lot of their intellectual qualities are not innate. Mostly it's due to a very severe work ethic and having had the leisure and wealth to pursue a field with single-minded focus since they were in their early teens. And much of this is mere bravado, or habitual oneupmanship learned from Ivy-league American schools. Don't be intimidated, and try not to abandon all your own intellectual standards in favor of Google's.
- amichail 17y agoDo you think entrepreneurs would be happy there? After all, many compelling ideas would not fair well with Google's data-driven evaluation (at least in the short term).
- elblanco 17y agoI think Google tries to use data-driven evaluation as a way to try to minimize the risk of failure seen in many startups. This has a downside too (beyond what I think you are thinking of). Lots of ideas actualize, and though they don't die, they also don't really go anywhere...witness the various non-monetizing products google has out there with fairly minimal user communities -- particularly against the competition.
- nostrademons 17y agoThere are a bunch of ex-entrepreneurs there, including myself. I think their happiness and success depends upon whether their entrepreneurial ideas align with the sorts of projects that Google would be good at, or whether they're better off striking out on their own again.
- lispm 17y agoFunny that all these super intelligent people at Google don't understand the need for 'privacy'. Even their boss' public statements about this issue seem to be pretty dumb.
- lispm 17y agoso who is downvoting this? People from Google or the NSA?
- simonk 17y agoParanoid a little? It was most likely downvoted because it has nothing to do with the article and was see as trolling.
- codexon 17y agoIt is marginally related to the article, both being about Google. It isn't fair to say that he was trolling just because half of his comment wasn't discussed in the blog post.
- lispm 17y agomy point is that these people who think their are intelligent, in fact are missing lots of facets from what we call 'intelligence'. From my point of view Google's employees are understanding a lot about technology and little about its social impact. It would help if they would not present them as super smart and act so clueless in so many ways.
- gyardley 17y agoWhile I enjoyed the article, and I appreciate you posting it, one quibble: it's off-putting whenever anyone mentions a number they got on a test as evidence for intelligence. If you write intelligently, I'll happily consider you intelligent.
- btilly 17y agoI normally don't do that. However for perspective I really wanted to give an idea of how intelligent I consider myself to be, and giving that relatively objective number sounded like the least assholish way I had to convey that to people who don't know me. You'll note that immediately upon giving the number I pointed out that there are issues with that method of measurement and gave an honest self-assessment whose upper range was well below what the number said.
- jlees 17y agoThat's a fairly common thing to do though. "My IQ is 200, but I don't believe in IQ tests. By the way did I mention my IQ was 200?" (Joking aside, I think you conveyed it pretty well, though I have no real clue what a GRE score of nearly 20 years ago means relatively speaking, or how you can convert it into a measure of intelligence at all...)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- btilly 17y agoI don't see the site I used to estimate my IQ before. But http://www.davidpbrown.co.uk/psychology/iq-conversion.html http://www.davidpbrown.co.uk/psychology/iq-conversion.html presents a calculator. And if you google around you can find other conversion charts that vary slightly from each other.
- dschobel 17y agoAgain... why worry about converting to/from a figure most people are skeptical of as representative of anything meaningful?
- elblanco 17y agoIt's kinda like an organization designed around the pinnacle of Maslow's Hierarchy of needs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslows_hierarchy_of_needs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslows_hierarchy_of_needs
- mixmax 17y agoSex and sexual intimacy seem to be sorely lacking from their organizational chart.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ovi256 17y agoIf it provides those too, it's called a cult, not a corporation.
- elblanco 17y agoTrue, but I always hear lots of talk about the group you are with. "My team eats together all the time." That kind of thing. From food on up the pyramid, Google consciously tries to provide something to provide something for each level.
- dschobel 17y agoThis leads to another point of interest. How astoundingly complex the company is. I believe that organizations naturally evolve until they are as complex as the people in them can handle. Well Google is tackling really big, complex problems, and is full of people who can handle a lot of complexity. What do you mean the company is complex? It's not clear to me why solving difficult problems merits organizational or operational complexity.
- btilly 17y agoTry to build something that deals with the amount of data that Google has, as quickly as Google handles it, with everything distributed, replicated, load balanced, and with failover to keep the site up when bad things happen anywhere in the system. (Which happens more often than we would like.) Before you're done you'll have built a lot of pieces of software that do different things that have complex little dependencies on each other. Now iterate that through many generations of development, and build some other systems that tackle similar problems. Do that and you'll discover why Google's infrastructure is complex.
- elblanco 17y agoQuick, slightly off-topic question. There's a belief in the industry (I think wrongly) that pretty much the only way to build big complex systems, you need a central "Enterprise Architect" to model all the business processes and use those to drive down to the technology. As somebody external to Google, it seems to me that this approach largely does not exist at Google (or if it does, it exists only for particular isolated pieces). Is this true? Or rather? What's Google's method for containing, directing and handling this complexity if it's not a traditional EA thinking process?
- btilly 17y agoExcellent question. I don't think I'm supposed to answer it. However Google's answer would be part of the, "nobody would believe me" piece of neilk's top-rated comment.
- aresant 17y ago"You are expected to. . . solve problems . . . Usually by email. The result is an organization which is in a constant state of flux . . . With . . . very large volumes of email." So now we understand Google Wave - they built it for themselves!
- Dove 17y agoI always assumed that was the case. Feel the same way about Office.
- mattiss 17y agoI mean this is interesting and all, but first page? Really? Does everybody want to work at Google that badly?
- logicalmind 17y agoOne thing I'd like to know about is how google deals with declines in productivity. Undoubtedly, their hiring process gets them highly qualified individuals, at least initially. But over time, there has to be people who become lazy and take advantage of their good graces. And it would be expected that as people age they start a family and their work priorities may take a back seat. Is there some kind of process, ala Jack Welch, where people are ranked and the bottom 10% are removed? How does google deal with under-performers?
- nostrademons 17y agoIt's the same as pretty much any big company - underperformers are notified that they're underperforming, put on a performance improvement plan to help improve their performance, and if they still don't improve, they're fired. There're no quotas for removing people (good riddance, the "fire the bottom 10%" school of management always struck me as the best way to create a poisonous, stressful company culture). But it's usually blatantly obvious who the underperformers are...they're the folks who haven't accomplished anything over the last 6 months...
- marltod 17y agoGoogle has it easy in this respect. At many other companies it can be hard to know if people are slacking off or just not that smart.
- roundsquare 17y agoTo be honest, what difference does it make? It may sound cruel, but why not just fire someone if they are not performing (given adequate time to improve, etc...). Please treat this as a genuine question - as someone who has only started working a few years ago and never had a management position, I feel my view is correct but am open to learning if/why I'm wrong.
- marltod 17y agoYou are correct. It doesn't matter, if someone is getting nothing done you can fire them unless their performance is due to a medical issue. I was referring to the people who get very little done. Other companies would love to hire only Google caliber employees but there isn't enough people to hire. So you end up with a company that may have a few superstars and a lot of average programmers. If a superstar slacked off they would have the same productivity as the average coders. It is hard for a manager to complain to that superstar when his productivity is just as good as many of his peers. At Google the slacker would stand out because his peers are all superstars and get A LOT done.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoHere's a question, and I don't mean this in a snarky way at all. It's a genuine question. With all these smart people, why has the experience of google search not improved substantially over the last 10 years? Sure, there's more little geegaws in search now, but the experience of finding what I want hasn't gotten any easier.
- brown9-2 17y agoI would assume that for most people, the experience of search is easy and is working well. Otherwise I don't think it would continue to be #1. It sounds like you might be outside the norm.
- waterlesscloud 17y agoThe fact that they're #1 just means they're the best of the available options. It doesn't mean the experience is great, just better than what else is out there.
- nostrademons 17y agoWhat are some of the tasks you've had a bad experience with? I work in Google Search, and we actively try to identify areas that people are having difficulty with and then come up with ways to make their search experience better. Unfortunately, most of the low-hanging fruit has already been picked. If we knew precisely where the pain points were, we'd be much better able to solve them.
- ojbyrne 17y agoSo I'm generally fine with Google as a great company until I deal with SEO people (i.e. the recent Mahalo discussion here). If you're all so great, why do we have to deal with so much pollution on the web?
- nostrademons 17y agoWhat are the combined resources thrown at gaming Google's search results? What are the combined resources thrown at preventing people from gaming Google's search results? The webspam team is big and staffed with some incredibly intelligent people, but there are probably millions of people out there that are all trying to figure out how to rank highly in search results.
- ojbyrne 17y agoIt's a reasonable counter-argument, but I don't buy it. 1. All those millions of people are competing against each other - many of them will cancel each other out. 2. It doesn't seem at all like google can't control spam, but that given well-funded companies (ideally from California) they look the other way. It seems less like a lack of resources and more like a lack of integrity.
- sown 17y agoi wish i was smart enough to work at google. :(
- danbmil99 17y agoTo listen to Googlers, Google is the frakking Chuck Norris of tech companies.
- GeorgeTirebiter 17y agoI'm not quite so sure that's an apt analogy. For instance, Chuck does not believe in evolution and subscribes to intelligent design. More about him at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuck_Norris http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chuck_Norris
- eleitl 17y agoThat blog post makes we want to punch the author in the face. Repeatedly.
- elblanco 17y agoSo Google is hiring? I only ever hear about the intense scrutiny engineers have to go through (and various quasi-discriminatory practices regarding school pedigree), but say I'm past the "I want to be an engineer" phase of my life and now work squarely in management. What's the process for that?
- ajaypopat 17y agoA question for googlers: what's the work-life balance like working over there? If you've worked at any of the other top tech companies, is it any better/worse than your previous gig?