4 ms·

GitLab Community Edition is fully open source and completely free: https://about.gitlab.com/features/#community https://about.gitlab.com/features/#community

by DouweM 11y ago

arihant 11y ago
I said if I wanted hosted option, then their only reliable option is $390 onboarding. Which is true. If I must go on-prem, then I might just use git directly? Meanwhile at Github, $7 gives me hosted private repos. It's free on Bitbucket if I limit collaborators. The biggest selling point of these services is peace of mind and knowing someone is taking care of the code when I sleep. Otherwise, Git has always been a FOSS.
- profmonocle 11y ago
  > If I must go on-prem, then I might just use git directly? Definitely. There's not much you can do with self-hosted GitLab that you can't do with pure git. GitLab just makes it easier, IMO. The main reason my company uses it is to restrict the master branch to certain people - doable with pure git, less effort with GitLab. There's no reason we couldn't use GitHub for this (wouldn't cost much for a team our size), but my company prefers on-prem whenever practical for various reasons. Self-hosted GitLab doesn't fit all the same uses as GitHub (I wouldn't use it for personal projects), but when it does fit it's great to have.
  - arihant 11y ago
    True. There is no denying that on-prem Gitlab has its uses. Maybe not for me, but I can respect that. The point I was making in the original comment was that Gitlab has absolutely no options without heavy onboarding that is hosted as well as reliable. I wasn't really undercutting their on-prem, just pointing out that comparisons with Github are heavily misplaced.
    - jobvandervoort 11y ago
      As said in other threads above, we are aware of the shortcomings of GitLab.com, but working very hard to resolve these [0]. Setting up your own instance is not hard [1], but we're also offering managed hosted instances on GitHost.io nowadays. If you're still in the middle, you could use the one-click deploy options from providers such as Digital Ocean, Cloud 66 and AWS images [2]. [0]: https://gitlab.com/gitlab-com/operations/issues/42 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-com/operations/issues/42 [1]: https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ [2]: https://about.gitlab.com/aws/#uw2 https://about.gitlab.com/aws/#uw2

GitLab Community Edition is fully open source and completely free: https://about.gitlab.com/features/#community https://about.gitlab.com/features/#community

by DouweM 11y ago

GitLab Community Edition is fully open source and completely free: https://about.gitlab.com/features/#community https://about.gitlab.com/features/#community

arihant 11y ago

I said if I wanted hosted option, then their only reliable option is $390 onboarding. Which is true. If I must go on-prem, then I might just use git directly? Meanwhile at Github, $7 gives me hosted private repos. It's free on Bitbucket if I limit collaborators. The biggest selling point of these services is peace of mind and knowing someone is taking care of the code when I sleep. Otherwise, Git has always been a FOSS.

profmonocle 11y ago
> If I must go on-prem, then I might just use git directly? Definitely. There's not much you can do with self-hosted GitLab that you can't do with pure git. GitLab just makes it easier, IMO. The main reason my company uses it is to restrict the master branch to certain people - doable with pure git, less effort with GitLab. There's no reason we couldn't use GitHub for this (wouldn't cost much for a team our size), but my company prefers on-prem whenever practical for various reasons. Self-hosted GitLab doesn't fit all the same uses as GitHub (I wouldn't use it for personal projects), but when it does fit it's great to have.
- arihant 11y ago
  True. There is no denying that on-prem Gitlab has its uses. Maybe not for me, but I can respect that. The point I was making in the original comment was that Gitlab has absolutely no options without heavy onboarding that is hosted as well as reliable. I wasn't really undercutting their on-prem, just pointing out that comparisons with Github are heavily misplaced.
  - jobvandervoort 11y ago
    As said in other threads above, we are aware of the shortcomings of GitLab.com, but working very hard to resolve these [0]. Setting up your own instance is not hard [1], but we're also offering managed hosted instances on GitHost.io nowadays. If you're still in the middle, you could use the one-click deploy options from providers such as Digital Ocean, Cloud 66 and AWS images [2]. [0]: https://gitlab.com/gitlab-com/operations/issues/42 https://gitlab.com/gitlab-com/operations/issues/42 [1]: https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ [2]: https://about.gitlab.com/aws/#uw2 https://about.gitlab.com/aws/#uw2