5 ms·
Cars and the Future
- Shivetya 11y agoWith regards to the simplicity implied with electronic propulsion I think far too many people vastly underestimate the complexity that is a battery pack, the regenerative systems, and propulsion motors. While electric motors are simple in theory they are very complex items on their own and long term viability has to be worked out. Throw in the packs weight alone requires juggling of the rest of the cars construction to get weight back down to acceptable levels. Self driving, yeah I think Google is doing fine for Disneyland type environments but the ever changing world of driving cannot be surmounted by data. It will take systems which can make microsecond decisions and actually know what they have perceived. So identification of all objects in play is key. the government approach of having cars all talk to each other seems opposite of where the car companies went. Last, ride sharing will likely get surpassed by automating buses of various sizes dynamically scheduled based on needs. Why there hasn't been a nationwide push to electrify school buses is beyond me, want to get a generation off to the right thinking fast, start with kids
- henrikschroder 11y ago> but the ever changing world of driving cannot be surmounted by data. That's insane, of course it can! How can you look at the current technological changes and come to the conclusion that there's an invisible barrier we're never going to pass? Given hardware that is fast enough, of course we can construct software to make microsecond decisions about the environment!
- viscanti 11y agoThe current technology is incredibly dependent upon high quality maps of the area. In theory that's a solvable problem, but it requires breakthroughs in mapping (it's prohibitively expensive to map to the degree needed for large areas), breakthroughs in reactions to unpredictable or untrained situations, breakthroughs in sensors that can work in poor climates (rain and snow) and breakthroughs in computing to be able to make it affordable once it's possible to process that. It's not impossible, but it's probably safe to say that it's currently insurmountable by data given current technology and the cost structures involved. Given several large, game-changing breakthroughs, of course it's possible.
- lern_too_spel 11y agoYour perception of current technology is decades behind where current technology is. Current technology can absolutely drive without high quality maps. It drives superhumanly well when it has access to those maps but just fine relative to human baseline without them.
- henrikschroder 11y agoYou're moving a bunch of goalposts here. Mapping isn't required at all for self-driving, it's required for self-navigation. Also, the obvious solution to mapping is to let every car provide input as they're driving. What do you think Google is doing with both Google Maps and Waze? They collect a shit-ton of data while people are using those apps and driving. There's your mapping. For untrained or unpredictable situations, you don't need a breakthrough, you just need the steady improvement of sensors and computer vision. You only need to encounter a situation once for the entire fleet of self-driving cars to be trained on it. For computing, you don't need breakthroughs, you just need more, and we're getting more, every year, steadily. Self-driving cars is not a matter of flashes of genius, it's a boring matter of economics of making the sensors cheap enough, the data collection cheap enough, the computing cheap enough, for it to be fitted to every car and there we go.
- zardo 11y agoFor mapping, you sensor up the cars you sell, SLAM, and send the data home. I'm not saying its easy, but you don't need to wait for someone to win a Nobel prize, Tesla started doing it last year.
- malandrew 11y agoOnce everything in the electric car gets as efficient as possible and electric cars reach the point where they are mass manufactured at a scale greatly exceeding combustion engines, we end up at the point where it makes sense to consider roadways as power lines and an automotive "third rail". The car could operate largely on capacitive energy or batteries designed to charge as quickly as possible to ~80% capacity and avoid trickle charging entirely. At the end of the day it's crazy to be accelerating and decelerating the mass of the batteries if you don't have to, and once you have a critical mass of electric vehicles on the road this just makes sense.
- sliverstorm 11y agoI'm rather incredulous about the whole, electric is simpler. Combustion engines are pretty damn simple, at their heart. Modern engines are complex monsters because we have been steadily refining them- lower emissions, more power, greater longevity. You have a whole host of devices managing the engine to make it perform optimally. Electric engines can also pretty damn simple. And yet we switch to brushless for durability. We thermally manage the battery banks for performance. We add regenerative modes for efficiency. I suspect eighty years from now, the electric engine will be just as complex if not more, than the combustion engine of today.
- blktiger 11y agoIt's not really about being simpler, but rather that electric has _fewer moving parts_. A modern gasoline car has hundreds of moving parts while an electric car has more like 1-4 moving parts (the motors). This means that the electric car is simpler to maintain. Think about all the important car maintenance items you have to pay for. Oil changes, belt replacements, transmission fluid changes, spark plugs, etc. On an electric car, you have a much smaller list of things to worry about. Basically you only need to replace the battery and the tires. Battery replacement should only need to be done every 5-10 years and tires should wear pretty much the same as in a gasoline car.
- robotresearcher 11y agoBrakes are consumables, too. Big batteries are very heavy so on the face of it this would eat brakes. On the other hand, recovery of power back to the battery helps to slow the car. Anyone know how this tradeoff works out? Does your Tesla zap its brakes quickly?
- neon_electro 11y agoAnecdotal evidence here - I drive a 2013 Nissan Leaf, and with its "B-Mode" (a drive mode that engages regenerative braking more strongly when you let off the accelerator pedal), I can do much more "braking"/slowing down in regular driving without engaging the friction brakes. Frequently, when approaching a stop light I can simply let off the gas and coast/regen down from 45mph to 15-10mph and then engage the friction brakes to stop.
- ufmace 11y agoGood article. It's pretty interesting to consider what the future of transportation looks like and which companies are in the best position to take advantage of it. I'm inclined to think that Uber may well have the best position on this. They may not have what it takes to put out the vehicle hardware or the self-driving software, but they do have the network and trust to set up self-driving, possibly electric, autonomous cars to substitute for conventional cars on at least some of their trips, from selected start and end locations. They're probably in the best position to make agreeable deals with whoever does end up making the best software.
- viscanti 11y agoThings like UberHop, where there's a pre-defined route seem like a logical first step. There's likely a large jump from that to fully autonomous vehicles that can drive on any road in any situation. But in that world, Uber (or Uber-like services) will have a jump on the competition as they'll have likely years of first-mover advantage, raising brand awareness about autonomous vehicles.
- exelius 11y ago> raising brand awareness about autonomous vehicles. IMO this is Uber's biggest strength. Once autonomous driving becomes even remotely real, investors would just be able to buy a bunch of cars, build a thin framework around some fleet management software and some payment processing, and have an Uber clone all of their own. Very little execution risk; the only requirements are capital investment. Uber has a built a powerful brand though, and will likely be the first choice of consumers. But Uber will still likely be at a disadvantage in this scenario. Companies able to offer only driverless cars will have a huge advantage in cost structure: not only does a startup not have to pay drivers a share, they also don't have the overhead associated with hiring, managing, interacting, dispute resolution, etc. with drivers. They can just ignore what amounts to an enormous part of Uber's operations. Sound familiar? It's exactly what Uber did to the taxi companies. Dispatching, metering, scheduling, etc. are all huge parts of taxi operations that Uber completely automates or ignores. Of course, the whole industry will probably just end up going the route of the airline industry -- hedge funds and investment banks put up the cash for the airplanes (cars) via a holding company, then insure them and lease them out to airlines, which actually operate them. The only people who will make anything from it will be the banks.
- FussyZeus 11y agoA good read, but it's another tech/car article that completely fails to take into account two huge things: Car Culture and things that aren't cities. On car culture: There is still an extremely large community of people in the U.S. (and I have no reason to believe this is restricted to the U.S) who buy cars NOT based on efficiency and price, we buy what we like. This is a huge factor that I've heard no technical pundit address yet. Excluding the Tesla which is a masterpiece, almost every other electric car is extremely dull. Lackluster styling, meh on performance, and focuses on gadgets to make the sale. To a "car guy," an electric car is right there with a Honda Accord or a Toyota Camry; it's mashed potatoes. It's a doughnut with no filling. Yeah, it will do the job and it will do it well, but you don't have any fun with it. When I'm going to out to spend a years salary or so on transportation I want something I'm going to enjoy driving. On the other thing, I have yet to see an even semi-autonomous car that can handle NOT being in a city. Intermittent Internet access, gravel/dirt roads, long stretches of unmarked highway, etc. I can't picture one of Google's cars making it's way up the driveway to my house, I have a feeling it would just stop at the edge of the driveway (dirt) and go "Welp, my tiny 8 inch tires can't handle an obstacle of that magnitude, get out and walk." I realize these are the concerns of a small market but when people throw around terms like "the car of the future" I feel the need to point out that it's not the future for everyone, and in fact might be the future for a very small group of people while everyone else keeps doing what they're doing.
- exelius 11y ago> Car Culture Well, "car culture" was invented to sell economy cars - nobody gets excited over mashed potatoes, so they had to invent something sexier. I don't think anyone legitimately believes that the auto industry is going to keel over and disappear - autonomous cars will have a very, very long adoption period. But over that period, I expect the "car guy" segment of the market (sports cars, etc) to become more of the niche hobby of "human-controlled car racing". It's not like horses totally disappeared after the invention of the automobile; their purpose just became much more heavily weighted towards entertainment. > things that aren't cities. Autonomous vehicles already exist that work in non-city environments. But yeah, there is probably some infrastructure that would need to be built first -- and it will get built, just like roads did. I expect we'll see autonomous cars in cities first, but the algorithms and hardware will improve over time and extend to rural areas. IMO we're about 15 years out from this entire debate being laughed at for how stupid we all were back in the mid-2010s :)
- erbo 11y agoWhat saddens me about all this is that the trend away from cars also represents a trend away from freedom. If you have a car that you can drive, you can travel pretty much as you please, subject to the availability of time and economic resources (e.g. fuel, vehicle maintenance). Without one, you are either restricted to the distance you can travel on foot (or via human-powered devices like bicycles, which extend that range some but not to a great extent), or you become dependent on others to provide you the service of transportation...and, in many cases, those services are either heavily regulated by government (e.g. airlines, trains, traditional taxi services) or outright provided by government (e.g. municipal buses and light rail). This gives the government the ability to arbitrarily deny the freedom to travel at its whim (e.g. the "no-fly" list). Of the three trends cited, electric cars least affect the freedom to travel, though their limited range compared to vehicles with an IC engine might infringe somewhat. Self-driving cars rely heavily on communication with external services for their navigation and operation, and this provides a chokepoint where government can exert pressure. And we've certainly seen how governments are responding to the rise of ride-sharing services, by attempting to regulate them, which is still an ongoing controversy. Is there anyone out there that is seriously addressing the threat to freedom that the demise of the traditional car represents?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lhopki01 11y agoWhat saddens me about the rise of cars is the loss of freedom. No longer can you travel where you want when you want on your horse, subject to the availability of grass and no cliffs. Now you will be limited the ares around gas stations, to the roads and the laws of government on those roads. Who will look out for our freedom that the demise of the horse represents?
- salmon30salmon 11y agoI think this is interesting, from a planning standpoint of today. In Portland, there is a huge effort to focus on pushing biking and transit as opposed to improving the quality and capacity of our roads. I find this interesting, only because the concept of a 4 wheeled automobile that is around 6 feet wide. Existing infrastructure will be heavily utilized by this no matter what the future brings. I am not an expert at all on city planning of course, and I realize its an incredibly complex field, but from a complete layman standpoint, investing in existing infrastructure today seems prudent.
- Zigurd 11y agoJust as high speed trains are lighter and less crash-worthy than slow trains, self-driving cards will evolve to be as light as reasonably possible while providing comfort. Lanes will become narrower, or allocated on demand. The extent of disruption is mostly underrated.