5 ms·
"Economic inequality may be caused by good things, but it is still bad" I think you're still making the same error as those primitive responses, because you're
by emmelaich 11y ago
"Economic inequality may be caused by good things, but it is still bad"
I think you're still making the same error as those primitive responses, because you're making that statement without qualification.
I suspect you don't realise how extreme your statement is percieved with the lack of qualification.
If one farmer works harder than the guy next door and becomes richer as a result, how is that bad?
If someone earning more than the median gets a payrise, they're contributing to poverty as defined in some countries.
See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron
- peteretep 11y agoTwo questions: -) Sergey Brin is worth $35,000,000,000. Has he worked 35,000 times harder or smarter than the 40-year-old Doctor who earns well and has scrimped and saved to $1m in net worth? -) Let's say you'd told Sergey - just as he was starting Google - in 20 years' time you'll have $10m in the bank from this. Do you think that would have encouraged or discouraged him?
- travisp 11y agoBrin has arguably created significantly more value than the 40-year-old Doctor. A doctor who likely uses Google to research medical information on a daily basis (as well as uses it for looking up personal information), possibly using a Google device, who gets from place to place using Google Maps, and searches for information for his next published paper on Google Scholar. (and so on, even putting aside the recent expansion of Google into Medical technology).
- peteretep 11y agoSure he has. Do you still think he'd have created it if he'd known final pay-out was a fraction of what it was? I suspect so...
- pj_mukh 11y agoI see your point, but it wouldn't have been possibly for him to build Google had it not been for people with MUCH more than $10M in their bank account to bankroll his growth.
- peteretep 11y agoSure it would, many smaller investors would have had to be found - it would have spread the wealth.
- tomhoward 11y agoAs someone who's tried funding a company that way, I can tell you it doesn't work. Companies like Google, Facebook, Dropbox and Airbnb all looked like crazy ideas to begin with. Ordinary people with limited funds shouldn't be investing in companies like these, as they fail far more often than not. It's only due to the existence of high-net-worth individuals, who can afford to lose money on most of their investments and who have a "pay it forward" mentality, that these companies can get their start. If the returns for people Page and Gates and Zuckerburg were capped at $10M, there's a good chance they wouldn't bother. For people like this, the goal is not personal enrichment but rather the ability to better the world, not just via their products, but also through philanthropy. Take away the blue sky returns, and you take the motive that is most beneficial to the rest of the world.
- dennisnedry 11y ago> Take away the blue sky returns, and you take the motive that is most beneficial to the rest of the world. I feel this to be the primary reason we have the technology and infrastructure we do today. Take the Robber Barons, for example, their pursuit of endless returns gave us the railroads, electricity for the masses, and cars. I guess the point is there is good with bad in everything. Sometimes the good outweighs the bad. That's how I am interpreting PG's original wealth inequality essay.
- T2_t2 11y ago
- vannevar 11y agoThere's a huge difference between 'significantly more value' and literally thousands of times more value. Had Brin been content to continue in academia after publishing his original research, and left the implementation and the riches to someone else, would we say that he had contributed virtually nothing? It's a myth that our economic system rewards people in direct proportion to the value they create.
- pcardh0 11y agoYes, Sergey Brin has worked 35,000 times smarter than the Doctor. I know this because the market has valued his share of his creation at 35B.
- ljw1001 11y agoI assume you also 'know' that the founders of Etsy are 75% less smart now that the market valuation of Etsy is 25% of its high. Market valuation measures nothing but what someone will pay for something today. It doesn't measure how smart or hard you worked.
- nothingnew 11y ago"I invented nothing new. I simply assembled the discoveries of other men behind whom were centuries of work. Had I worked fifty or ten or even five years before, I would have failed. So it is with every new thing. Progress happens when all the factors that make for it are ready and then it is inevitable. To teach that a comparatively few men are responsible for the greatest forward steps of mankind is the worst sort of nonsense." - Henry Ford
- vannevar 11y agoIf one farmer works harder than the guy next door and becomes richer as a result, how is that bad? It isn't. But if one farmer works harder than another, wealthier farmer, and the wealthier farmer makes 1000 times more than the harder working farmer, that is bad. And that is how the system currently works: we systematically reward people for being wealthy, regardless of any personal qualities or talents. And whereas there is a natural upper bound on how hard you can work, or how clever you can be (we're all human beings, after all), there is no upper bound on how wealthy you can be, and therefore no upper bound on the advantage you can be born with. It's tough to work 1000 times harder than someone else, but trivial to earn 1000 times more from investments if you have 1000 times more to begin with.