2 ms·
If the brain was scale-invariant, it wouldn't matter whether you studied the large-scale behaviour or the small-scale behaviour (like the criticized Blue Brain
by barrkel 11y ago
If the brain was scale-invariant, it wouldn't matter whether you studied the large-scale behaviour or the small-scale behaviour (like the criticized Blue Brain project); both would tell you the same thing. But like noobermin, I think they mean something else.
But that aside, it's not clear to me that studying the behaviour of the smallest part of a complex system doesn't tell you something about the behaviour of the whole, even when that behaviour isn't necessarily clear from the smallest part considered in isolation. Specifically, simulation and emulation rely on precise models at some level of abstraction, but can then be scaled up to try and simulate aggregate behaviour.
Things like finite element analysis or soft body dynamics work on the basis of modelling a small part of a system in order to produce a large-scale aggregate model. Understanding the small parts more precisely leads to a better aggregate model because, given sufficient computing power, we can easily scale the model up.
Whether the larger model gives you understanding is arguable; but it can certainly give you information on how sensitive the whole is to the attributes of the part, and makes experiments on the simulated whole much easier.