5 ms·
In the case anyone like me was confused about their use of the term "scale invariance", I'll say that for physicists, as the name implies, scale invariance deal
by noobermin 11y ago
In the case anyone like me was confused about their use of the term "scale invariance", I'll say that for physicists, as the name implies, scale invariance deals with a symmetry of a system under a change of scale, say of the dynamics or the lagrangian[0]. However, it seems that a quick 10 second google seems to imply to me that neuroscientists and the like use scale invariance to refer to self-similarity[1]. This might be what the author means here.
[0] Specifically, a scaling of the system corresponds to a simple scaling of the Lagrangian. See
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scale_invariance#Scale_invariance_in_quantum_field_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scale_invariance#Scale_invaria...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scale_invariance#Fractals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scale_invariance#Fractals
- gbhn 11y agoIsn't the other side of the coin, though, that in these types of systems you can actually get a lot "wrong" and they still work? That is, in the example of a sand pile, if you get the rate of adding sand "wrong", it doesn't really matter: much the same thing happens. That's kind of the whole point. Whether that means that in simulating the brain it may turn out that you can get a lot wrong and still have a successful outcome is TBD, but I'm not sure the expectations are as solidly negative as the article suggests.
- ericflo 11y agoI think it was meant in the sense that the "criticality" could involve just a few neurons or many, but if for example we could learn how to detect it, that detector would need to work regardless of the scale of the event. In CV there's a well known algorithm called Scale-Invariant Feature Transform, which does basically this.