3 ms·
> Docker is ultimately a non-solution that papers over the problems of traditional system package managers, language-specific package managers, and the myriad o
by eropple 11y ago
> Docker is ultimately a non-solution that papers over the problems of traditional system package managers, language-specific package managers, and the myriad of software (mostly Java) that no one actually knows how to build from source.
It's interesting that you saythis--I would say almost the exact opposite here: most of the Java applications are the best-behaved on systems I deal with, both in terms of execution (it's in the Maven repo) and in terms of process control (cgroups are nice for, like, a Ruby app, but here I've got -Xmx). The poorly behaved ones seem to be ones that don't use standard tools, and maybe I've been lucky but for me that's all third-party and mostly open-source stuff; a lot of new-hotness stuff (Kafka, I am looking at you, I love you but you are a pain in the behind to deploy) can't just be run straight out of the Maven repository with a bash script or whatever.
About the only place I use containerization at all (and I don't use Docker, for reasons I've described elsewhere around here) is for Ruby or Python applications where otherwise I do end up with stuff thrown all over the place and multiple versions of the runtime fighting for supremacy. I'd love to use Guix/Nix, but it's a hard fight to win in a corporate environment.
> Using Docker to solve this problem is like using a sledgehammer to drive a nail.
I wish to upvote this eleven times. I can but do so only once.
- thinkpad20 11y ago> I'd love to use Guix/Nix, but it's a hard fight to win in a corporate environment. I don't know how large or flexible your organization is, but I've been driving hard at my company (which is a bit shy of 100 employees) for using nix, and it's working. When I started advocating for it there was no small amount of skepticism, but we started off just using it for a very small and specific use case, and from there it has slowly but steadily gained acceptance from other developers (most of whom have no particular interest in FP) as a real solution to innumerable problems that we have w.r.t. package management. If you're interested in Guix/Nix, I'd encourage trying to get permission to use it to solve a specific problem.
- eropple 11y agoI'm a consultant. While I can push for a lot if it's conventional, but I have to pick my battles. That's not one I feel I can win.