3 ms·
After watching the Florida landing a number of times, and taking into account that this maneuver is made more difficult by the fact that at its lowest thrust se
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
After watching the Florida landing a number of times, and taking into account that this maneuver is made more difficult by the fact that at its lowest thrust setting just one engine has more thrust than the booster weighs, trying to reach 0,0 velocity at a point and time, where the point is moving (the platform is rising and sinking in the swells) is likely not possible.
As I understand it, deep sea oil drilling platforms provide stability by using a very large "keel" under the platform with air pumps to keep the overall displacement relatively constant so that the platform's position relative to the drill is maintained (the drill being in the sea bed). The SeaLaunch vehicle that Boeing built has similar sorts of compensation strategies.
And that is a problem in that if you have to recover to land, you limit the missions where you can recover and that will impact the bonus of recoverable stages.
One wonders if there is some way to adapt a technique the Navy uses for landing helicopters in rough seas, where the helicopter "hooks" the deck and then applies a net positive collective to hold that line under tension, then the line is winched in bringing the helicopter down to the deck. Meanwhile the helicopter has matched the pitching of the deck because it is pulling against the tether at that point. A very complex system and I cannot fathom the challenge of building something like that on an autonomous landing barge.
- zappo2938 11y agoUsing a tether is the same as in med mooring a yacht. [1] The anchor is released and tight while the engines are in reverse. It's possible with a windlass to slowly take up or release more anchor chain. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1rUXmzdtMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1rUXmzdtMY
- ufmace 11y agoGot any videos of that Navy technique? Can't say I've heard of it, and a few minutes of Youtube searches don't find anything. I have been in helicopters landing on ships at sea, though not in rough seas, and they didn't do anything particularly special. The helicopters did have landing gear with suspension and shock absorbers, though. I wonder how much shock absorption capability the F9 landing legs have, and if they can add in some more.
- ChuckMcM 11y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAbm2XDpx9w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tAbm2XDpx9w The video above shows the technique being practiced. I actually saw it as part of a show on small helicarriers that the Marines use, probably the show "Firepower" or "Wings" there was a period of time when I was researching military equipment in support of an RTS game design and I went through hours of documentary type shows to understand the capabilities around modern (late 20th century) weaponry.