4 ms·
From webcast just now: - Landing was on target - hard landing - landing leg broke - not standing upright. footage later (in a few hours)
by grecy 11y ago
From webcast just now: - Landing was on target - hard landing - landing leg broke - not standing upright.
footage later (in a few hours)
- atroyn 11y agoI wonder if it exploded this time, last time they didn't stay upright the remaining fuel ignited and it blew up.
- agumonkey 11y agoGood point, no fuel no boom.
- greglindahl 11y agoWith some left-over LOX and kerosene, of course it blew up. Rockets don't stay in one piece after they fall over.
- atroyn 11y agoI wonder how much of both there was left though. If they can salvage the engine it still might be a success. It would also depend on when the leg broke - do they vent any unspent LOX/Kerosene after they land?
- JshWright 11y agoYou could vent the LOX. "Venting" the kerosene would just mean dumping it all over the deck. That doesn't seem like an awesome option... My guess is there was 'plenty' of propellant left (to use a technical term for quantity...). The rocket could have flown back to the launch site, but they weren't able to get environmental clearance. While they may have adjusted the trajectory to take advantage of the downrange landing (letting the first stage burn longer), they wouldn't have had any reason to skimp on the propellant left over for landing, so I'm sure there was a healthy margin left in the tanks. More than enough for an impressive fireball.
- polack 11y agoWhat is the reason they cut the stream for events like this? Just so they can shift focus by writing a press release saying how they could salvage the most important stuff before the video hits the news?
- atroyn 11y agoThey didn't cut the stream, the satellite link to the drone ship failed - SpaceX wasn't getting telemetry either.
- polack 11y agoOK, thanks for the clarification. Guess that could indicate something worse took place after the leg breaking then :(
- ncallaway 11y agoIt could indicate that, but the satellite connection that far out at sea is pretty flaky. A standard landing — with engine exhaust could also have cut the feed. Hell, even the pitching of the ocean could be enough to break the satellite connection. I think we'll have to wait and see to know more.
- mcpherrinm 11y agoThe video feed from the drone ship is via satellite. You need a gyro system to keep the dish pointed at your satellite. These systems often can't keep up in rough seas.
- maxander 11y agoThere's a crucial bit of ambiguity there- when they say "on-target," do they mean that the rocket is now sitting on the barge with a broken leg, or did it bounce off and explode like on the previous attempts?
- dlgeek 11y agoMy guess: Hit the target, leg broke, rocket tipped over, then exploded. Especially when empty, the main structure is very fragile - having the side hit the barge would almost certainly rupture it, resulting in a boom.
- manicdee 11y agoYes, just without the "exploded". https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/688837706005131264 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/688837706005131264 Rocket lying on its side, bottom end looks a mess though. There was apparently some level of deflagration.
- jffry 11y agoDepends on what you count as exploding. It was definitely fiery: https://www.instagram.com/p/BAqirNbwEc0/ https://www.instagram.com/p/BAqirNbwEc0/
- ChuckMcM 11y agoAfter watching the Florida landing a number of times, and taking into account that this maneuver is made more difficult by the fact that at its lowest thrust setting just one engine has more thrust than the booster weighs, trying to reach 0,0 velocity at a point and time, where the point is moving (the platform is rising and sinking in the swells) is likely not possible. As I understand it, deep sea oil drilling platforms provide stability by using a very large "keel" under the platform with air pumps to keep the overall displacement relatively constant so that the platform's position relative to the drill is maintained (the drill being in the sea bed). The SeaLaunch vehicle that Boeing built has similar sorts of compensation strategies. And that is a problem in that if you have to recover to land, you limit the missions where you can recover and that will impact the bonus of recoverable stages. One wonders if there is some way to adapt a technique the Navy uses for landing helicopters in rough seas, where the helicopter "hooks" the deck and then applies a net positive collective to hold that line under tension, then the line is winched in bringing the helicopter down to the deck. Meanwhile the helicopter has matched the pitching of the deck because it is pulling against the tether at that point. A very complex system and I cannot fathom the challenge of building something like that on an autonomous landing barge.
- zappo2938 11y agoUsing a tether is the same as in med mooring a yacht. [1] The anchor is released and tight while the engines are in reverse. It's possible with a windlass to slowly take up or release more anchor chain. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1rUXmzdtMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1rUXmzdtMY
- ufmace 11y agoGot any videos of that Navy technique? Can't say I've heard of it, and a few minutes of Youtube searches don't find anything. I have been in helicopters landing on ships at sea, though not in rough seas, and they didn't do anything particularly special. The helicopters did have landing gear with suspension and shock absorbers, though. I wonder how much shock absorption capability the F9 landing legs have, and if they can add in some more.
- 11y ago