3 ms·
It all looks nice until we get numbers from groups like GapJumpers that institute blind auditions for hiring or performance evaluations where evaluator can't id
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
It all looks nice until we get numbers from groups like GapJumpers that institute blind auditions for hiring or performance evaluations where evaluator can't identify what group they are. Starting out, these "fair" companies are usually under 10% minority or women. Once they see only performance, it's suddenly closer to 50/50. Hmm.
Then there's the experiences themselves:
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jan/12/silicon-valley-women-harassment-gender-discrimination http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jan/12/silicon-va...
Would you work in a place or field like that if all you heard was what's in above link? And people justified it instead of solved it? And hard data, such as pay or hiring w/ performance in context, showed they discriminated in both hiring and advancement? Probably not.
The problems are in the Valley's culture and decision-making, not anything intrinsic. Same as in most other places. Good policies on professionalism, hiring, and promotion which focus on performance instead of identity would go a long way. Have, in few companies that did it.
- brighteyes 11y agoI would be interested to see a source for the "blind auditions" claim. Some reasons for skepticism about blind auditions making a difference in tech: 1. Github provides a potential blind audition scenario - don't mention your race or age or gender or weight or anything else. Just submit code and prove yourself. Yet, diversity advocates generally see this as not helping minorities in tech. 2. Tech companies constantly publish their diversity stats. They are trying to hire more women and minorities, and are motivated to do so. Blind auditions tend to help in industries where the opposite is true. Still, I'd love to see a source for your claim, and I'd be happy to be convinced otherwise. Regarding the one link you do provide: The headline figure is meaningless without some more data on the survey - such as how was the survey conducted, and is it random. If it's not random, then it's very hard to judge how valid it is.
- malandrew 11y agoI too want to see citations for the above poster's assertions. I'm also curious to see a citation for this statement, "Just submit code and prove yourself. Yet, diversity advocates generally see this as not helping minorities in tech.", since I'm curious to read their reasoning. I actually would expect and hope that such a process doesn't help minorities. I also would expect and hope that it also doesn't help those that are not minorities. After all, isn't a fair, blind process the most just approach we can hope for? However, I think this is where there is a big, largely unrecognized schism, and that is the schism between those that advocate for equality and those that advocate for equity. Those two unfortunately are not the same. I personally am an advocate for equality. +1 for understanding study methodology and what biases may be present. AFAIK, the study is this one here, http://elephantinthevalley.com/ http://elephantinthevalley.com/ They state the criteria for including a respondent in the survey, but I didn't find out if the 200+ women included in the study were randomly sampled from all women they "found" who met the criteria or if this represented the entire population of all the women they "found" who met that criteria. An explanation of how they were "found" was also absent. The final sentence in the introductory block "We encourage you to read, discuss, and add your anonymous stories to this initiative." suggests that self selection bias may influence these figures. I submitted the following comment on the site: "Could you please add a section on your site describing in detail the study/survey methodologies used? I'm particularly interested in knowing more about how survey participants were selected.". I wish all studies and surveys like this voluntarily shared their methodology along with their results. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-selection_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-selection_bias
- nickpsecurity 11y agoComment was too long lol. Replied here then: http://pastebin.com/8nacUX06 http://pastebin.com/8nacUX06
- malandrew 11y agoCitation for that first paragraph and last sentence please. I can see a demonstration of 50/50 in a controlled study, but I don't see how you get to 50/50 at a real company in this industry in the Bay Area without actively discriminating against those who meet the hiring criteria and are not women or minority, since 50/50 is so far from the base rate of potential applicants available to hire from. To answer your question, yes, I would work in a place or field like that if that is all I heard in the above link, because I also know that nothing I read in that article is isolated solely to tech companies in Silicon Valley. AFAIK (and I haven't seen numbers otherwise), everything described in that article happens in many industries and many regions, including other industries I've personally worked in or with previously that weren't tech and weren't in the Bay Area (or necessarily the United States) (including one industry that is mostly female). I'm not saying that we shouldn't address and change the culture so these unfortunate problems don't happen to anyone, but painting one industry and region as being uniquely a bad apple does a lot to deprive good people interested in that industry from entering it in the first place, leaving those already there further isolated. I work/worked at one of Silicon Valley's many unicorns on the same team as one of the women who founded the female engineering group at the company and who champions the hiring of more women and one of the greatest challenges I heard her complain regularly about when trying to recruit women to improve our ratios was trying to overcome how the biased tech media likes/liked to portray our company (and any unicorn once it starts experiencing success). I heard of several instances where a woman turned down our offers and went to work elsewhere merely on account of what the media said despite my colleagues claims to the candidate otherwise. The way I see it, the chicken little sky is falling way of talking about things highlights problems but also actively discourages people from joining and making it better. Lots of great female engineers declined a seat on a rocket ship on account of what was being said, and I have no idea how many more didn't even consider applying in the first place. There are ways to highlight and address the problem without discouraging people from coming to work in tech. I would love to see a comparative analysis of the transgressions in your linked article across multiple industries. Raising awareness for these problems everywhere helps get them solved, but raising awareness for these problems in one particular industry is both productive and counterproductive as it highlights the problem while simultaneously discouraging people from entering that industry to expedite those solutions. Before I conclude this comment, I want to be very clear that I wholeheartedly agree that everything in that linked article is a problem and needs to be improved, but my particular complaint above and in this comment is about people who seek results without applying logic and rationality to understand the problem and don't also apply logic and rationality before arriving at solutions. Basically, a society that demonstrates logic and rationality is the social cause I most advocate for above all other social causes because it keeps all other social causes and those that advocate for them honest and grounded in reason. In fact, this colleague who took on the important work of trying to recruit more female candidates started out as one of those women who had a job offer at our unicorn and went to work at another unicorn on a different coast with a better reputation first and ended up back at our unicorn less than a year later finding out that while our reputation was worse, our conditions were better (but still need improvement).