4 ms·
I think the writer fundamentally misunderstands Schoenberg's approach, and the approach of many avant-garde composers. Schoenberg was engaged in an experiment.
by jdietrich 11y ago
I think the writer fundamentally misunderstands Schoenberg's approach, and the approach of many avant-garde composers.
Schoenberg was engaged in an experiment. His polemic was not an absolute statement on the future of music, but a hypothesis. It is a framework for experimentation, like the Dogme 95 movement in film. The point of an artistic manifesto is to push a particular idea to an extreme and see what happens.
To quote Vi Hart: "It's a tool for breaking free of old musical habits ... to get your brain to stop following the same, well-worn neural pathways and think something you haven't thought before."
Schoenberg's legacy wasn't a generation of musicians who dogmatically stuck to serialist principles, but a generation who had a deep intuition about the limits of tonality. Eisler studied under Schoenberg, combining serialist ideas with jazz and folk music. He created some of the most remarkable and powerful music of the 20th century.
The work of the classical avant garde fed into jazz in a profound way. George Russell's Lydian Chromatic Concept of Tonal Organisation was integral to some of the most important jazz works of the post-bop period. Most notably, that includes Miles Davis' Kind of Blue, by far the most popular and accessible jazz album of all time.
Music is a conversation played out over centuries, a back-and-forth of ideas. Sometimes a conversation needs polite consensus, sometimes it needs daring new ideas, sometimes it needs someone to say "this is all bollocks".
Music needs people like Schoenberg, just as software needs people like RMS. The progress of culture depends on the grand pronouncements of obsessive lunatics.
- Joeboy 11y ago> Music needs people like Schoenberg, just as software needs people like RMS. The progress of culture depends on the grand pronouncements of obsessive lunatics. Maybe culture also needs people like Roger Scruton, for the same kind of reason.