4 ms·
As an European I found this very interesting: > There is a reason that blacks appear to have been spared the worst of the narcotic epidemic, said Dr. Andrew Ko
by paganel 11y ago
As an European I found this very interesting:
> There is a reason that blacks appear to have been spared the worst of the narcotic epidemic, said Dr. Andrew Kolodny, a drug abuse expert. Studies have found that doctors are much more reluctant to prescribe painkillers to minority patients, worrying that they might sell them or become addicted.
If I read this correctly the doctors' pervasive racism is keeping young black men alive.
- chillydawg 11y agoHelping you by hurting you!
- paulddraper 11y agoInstead of hurting you by helping you.
- palish 11y agoIt would be good to read the study's paper. Studies often don't reach any explicit conclusions, which is one of the important features of the scientific process. Other people make inferences that aren't supported by the actual findings. Some studies are intentionally deceptive, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=97299 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=97299. I've pointed that one out a few times over the years, since it's such an excellent showcase of incentives gone wrong. The researcher ended up getting a lot of funding, partly thanks to the pretense of "rat brain flies plane." No one bothered to try to pull apart their paper. It takes a lot of effort to do this. The only reason I spent hours reverse engineering that paper was because of how excited I was about the implications. Discovering that it was nothing more than a rube goldberg nearly shattered my faith in academia. Especially the realization that sometimes researchers have to do that sort of thing to get funding, or lose. It's entirely possible that what you said is true. All I'm saying is, it's best to seek out the original paper. (If it's locked behind a paywall, post a request to /r/scholar and you'll usually get it in under an hour.) Sometimes the truth is quite different from appearances.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoStudies have also shown inter-group empathy gaps. Or, basically, white people don't believe black people's pain [to the same extent], similarly with men and women. That's probably also a factor.
- finid 11y ago> Or, basically, white people don't believe black people's pain If a guy is rushed into the ER, you, as a doctor or nurse, don't have to believe anything. Just run the patient through the proper protocols, regardless of race, age or gender. Otherwise what's the Hippocratic Oath all about?
- carbocation 11y agoThe same is true for hiring, etc. Sitting here behind computer monitors we see the solution so clearly: to stop racism, just ignore race. But out in the real world after we step away from these screens, the futility of that demand becomes clear. You and I commit implicitly biased acts on a routine basis that we don't even notice. Doctors don't under-treat black patients' pain because they explicitly dislike black people. They do so due to implicit bias. You cannot admonish people into shedding their implicit biases. The solution is to build a system that is resilient to implicit bias.
- finid 11y agoBias is a built-in human feature. In fact, all living things are hard-wired to discriminate. So your "implicit bias" is right. Most of the time we engage in it unconsciously. Sometimes that "implicit bias shows up as racism, nepotism or some other form of favoritism. > Doctors don't under-treat black patients' pain because they explicitly dislike black people. They do so due to implicit bias. No necessarily true. A racist doctor will under-treat black patients simply because he's racist. And note that I'm referring to a racist doctor, because not all white doctors are racist.
- brookside 11y agoOk but the opioid pain medication would be prescribed after the dust has settled from that ER scramble. Doctors don't have a way to measure pain, other then the patient's own reporting (often they are asked to describe it on the scale of 1-10). So belief is a central part of the process.
- finid 11y agoA case of unintended consequences, though, in this case, good. In other situations, confirmed by many studies, racism in emergency rooms (and hospitals in general) have been very bad for blacks.
- TrevorJ 11y agoIt sounds like white patients should be experiencing the same scrutiny but aren't.