2 ms·
If extremely wealthy venture capitalists don’t want to have their motives questioned when they write essays full of unsupported and self-serving arguments and d
by jacobolus 11y ago
If extremely wealthy venture capitalists don’t want to have their motives questioned when they write essays full of unsupported and self-serving arguments and demonstrating a severe lack of empathy/social understanding, then they shouldn’t post them on the internet.
Dan: I’m sure Paul Graham and this site will both be fine whether or not you you tell his critics to keep their opinions to themselves.
(Side note: literally nobody is going to confuse my idiomatic use of quotation marks to offset a sarcastic summary of an argument which I claim is as old as civilization for a direct quotation from any particular person.)
In the general genre of PG criticism, my comments are treating him with kid gloves. For a more vigorous and amusing analysis of his essays’ analytical rigor, Maciej Cegłowski provides a gem, as expected, still just as relevant ten years later: http://idlewords.com/2005/04/dabblers_and_blowhards.htm http://idlewords.com/2005/04/dabblers_and_blowhards.htm
- apsec112 11y ago"I think Hannah Arendt said that one of the great achievements of Stalinism was to replace all discussion involving arguments and evidence with the question of motive. If someone were to say, for example, that there are many people in the Soviet Union who don't have enough to eat, it might make sense for them to respond, "It's not our fault, it was the weather, a bad harvest or something." Instead it's always, "Why is this person saying this, and why are they saying it in such and such a magazine? It must be that this is part of a plan."" - Christopher Hitchens
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoNone of that addresses what I said.
- jacobolus 11y agoHere’s a more carefully elaborated version of the criticism of Graham’s sloppy thinking and lazy writing from his inequality essay: https://glyph.twistedmatrix.com/2016/01/premises.html https://glyph.twistedmatrix.com/2016/01/premises.html Since life is short, that’s it for me for this thread.
- dang 11y agoYou're acting as if the correctness of pg's views is relevant to your misconduct on this site. But the two have nothing to do with each other. It's against the values (and rules) of HN to misrepresent what someone said or personally attack them in order to vent your spleen, regardless of how wrong they are.
- throwawaymaroon 11y agoPretty dodgy road you've found yourself on, dang. Evaluating whether or not a criticism of an essay is unfair is equivalent to evaluating whether that criticism is true. It's pretty easy to take "hostility towards PG's points is forbidden" away from this moderation. It might not be entirely, technically true in every single interpretation, particularly the charitable ones you'll apply to yourself, but it's true enough. I guess I can't be mad at you for protecting the rich people that pay your check.