3 ms·
I've always wondered how efficient are traditional bulbs as an actual heat source? I live in Minnesota and its -17°F outside, and would it be more energy effici
by donatj 11y ago
I've always wondered how efficient are traditional bulbs as an actual heat source? I live in Minnesota and its -17°F outside, and would it be more energy efficient to heat the room I am currently occupying with the light bulbs of the room, keeping the rest of the house cooler than pumping a higher level of heat to the entire house?
I feel like the switch to CFLs may have increased my energy bills overall.
- repsilat 11y agoThey're somewhere in the vicinity of 100% efficient as heat producers. Even the energy that goes into producing light just decays into heat after bouncing off a couple of walls. Less "efficient" than using a "heat pump," and possibly more expensive than using gas (I don't know anything about energy in Minnesota). If you're using electricity to heat your home, though, you might as well use something like SETI@home and put it to use :-)
- tempestn 11y agoUnfortunately you can't use a heat pump (at least a normal one) below about -8C (17F), so -17F would definitely be out. I also don't know anything about energy in Minnesota, but here in BC, gas heating is still cheaper than electric, especially if you use an efficient gas furnace (that doesn't exhaust too much heat), but not as much as it used to be. (Technically though it will always be less "efficient" than electric due to that exhaust, but that's really comparing apples to oranges.)
- lscharen 11y agoThat's true for air heat pumps, but many people (myself included) have ground water heat pump systems; either open- or closed-loop. My unit is fairly old (mid 1980 Tetco) and provide all of our heating and cooling. It uses the most electricity in January/February for heating and July/August for cooling, but my total electric bill is usually never more than $200/mo and that included all of the home's "normal" electricity use.
- danans 11y agoIf you mean lifecycle efficiency, then it depends on the fuel used to generate the electricity. If it's coal or natural gas then pretty inefficient to use electricity for resistive heating since the heat byproduct of combustion was lost at the generating power plant. If the energy source is wind or solar, then it's very efficient as there is no heat loss in generation. Both scenarios involve the inherent transmit losses of electricity distribution (15%?). Natural gas has little transmission loss, and modern condensing furnaces reclaim much of the waste heat from the combustion exhaust. You can also zone a Nat gas heating system so it only heats the areas you want at any time. Also heating with electrical resistance will be very expensive as the cost per unit of energy for electricity is much higher than natural gas.