3 ms·
The best computer software is the kind that reminds people to dance and shows them some steps. Vonnegut, like so many people, imagines computers can only suck
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
The best computer software is the kind that reminds people to dance and shows them some steps.
Vonnegut, like so many people, imagines computers can only suck the life out of things. I suppose we deserve that reputation, since so many of us write software that does.
- jv22222 11y agoSoftwar swings both ways. Some productivity software saves hours, months or years by maximizing efficiency. On the otherhand games and social media sure do suck up a lot of time.
- mercer 11y agoWhile at the same time, software that maximizes efficiency (todo apps, etc.) can cause anxiety and increase the risk of mindlessly checking off todo items without considering their value (I've experienced this), and games and social media can provide lasting, valuable experiences and friendships. The computer is a neutral tool that can make good things better and bad things worse. Because still a relatively new invention, and undergoing constant, rapid change in how it affects culture and individual behavior (pocket computers! VR! etc!), we haven't quite figured out how to distinguish the two. In some cases this means that we unexpectedly find a wonderful application that improves countless lives, and in some cases it means that we discover ways in which the use of a computer can affect us or society negatively. Personally, I am generally in favor of change, in the broadest sense, even if sometimes it's bad, while paradoxically I myself don't deal well with changes. The thing I love about computers is that they are one of the biggest instruments of change, and yet in my interactions with computers they are wonderfully boring and predictable, in the end. I have a theory that this is one aspect of computers that draws so many people like me to them. I have access to a vast world of experience, knowledge and people while using a tool that I control, usually from the comforts of my home. And using that same tool, in the same comfortable setting, I can create things that somehow affect (and ideally benefit) many people, through writing, coding, 'drawing', and most importantly the internet. That said, of course going out into the world is still an activity that is important for happiness, at least for most people. But the fact that I live in a time where I can create, learn, consume, bond, and so on, with this one tool and an internet connection is something I'm very thankful for.
- noir_lord 11y agoI'm in the middle of writing some software that is in the "reminds people to dance" category, it's not about making anyone rich (including myself) but about making peoples lives measurably better and easier, hopefully lots of peoples lives. It was something I only realised I could do through shitty things that happened over the last few years but working on it has given me a peace I've been missing a long time - I've found it's way too easy to get caught up in the day to day of keeping up with the field we are in, everything moves so quickly I started to feel like if I got off the bus I'd never be able to catch back up..but the thing is another bus usually turns up (if it's a UK bus it'll be late though..).
- jaredklewis 11y agoI don't think Vonnegut meant "dancing" in a particularly figurative way. I think he means it in the sense of physically moving your body. Computers are great in my book, but I agree with Vonnegut that usage of them tends to result in less physical activity.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoI didn't mean it figuratively either!
- sanderjd 11y agoWhat struck me when I read that quote (as a Vonnegut loving computer nerd) was that computers at their best free up time to "dance"! That's the promise of a future where computers do most of our work for us: that we'll have tons of time to do whatever we enjoy doing. But instead, we're mostly scared of it, because we aren't sure what we'll do to make money if that happens, because we need money to buy ourselves the time to "dance". It's a real conundrum.