3 ms·
One thing the article doesn't analyze at all: standing on both sides improves total throughput, but how does it affect the individual latency for people walking
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
One thing the article doesn't analyze at all: standing on both sides improves total throughput, but how does it affect the individual latency for people walking up the left side? If the answer is "it's faster for them too", then tell people that and they'll be more inclined to go along with it. And if the answer is "it's slower for them", then no wonder they don't want to go along with it.
- narag 11y agoAlso the "faster for everyone" as a goal ignores that people that will go faster with this system is people that were in no big rush to begin with (so they took the right side), while people that wanted to go faster now can't. You take away something that some people wanted to give the rest something nobody asked for.
- jschwartzi 11y agoBut the metric is overall throughput, not latency. If they had bothered to characterize latency then that conclusion would probably follow. Since they characterized throughput instead, they optimized throughput at the expense of latency.
- MaysonL 11y agoConsider those rushing left-side walkers: with left-side walking in effect, at peak times, they may have to wait a few minutes at the bottom of the escalator to get on, while their walking will save them 30 seconds on the trip up. Not worth it. 16,220 per hour, versus 12,745.
- Symbiote 11y agoIn some cases, the available space for queueing is quite limited. If too many people are queuing, so this mass extends to the platforms, it might not be safe to let a train depart. Anecdote: During rush hour, I was almost at the bottom of an escalator at Oxford Circus station, when a women a little ahead of me fell over, and the man in front of me fell over her. I pressed the emergency stop button, and blocked the way for people coming down until someone had helped the woman stand. Less than a minute later, a London Underground employee finds me on the platform and thanks me for acting quickly¹. He says the crowding at the top of the escalator — in a minute! — means the station has been partially closed "exit and interchange only". (Probably only for five minutes.)