8 ms·
A nanophotonic comeback for incandescent bulbs?
- CountHackulus 11y agoInteresting technology, and it'll be fun to see how they market the technology since people just started understanding that incandescent = lots of energy = money. I wonder if LED technology will be able to keep up.
- Animats 11y agoThey've developed a photonic crystal [1] which reflects IR while passing visible light. That should be useful. Using it to to try to reflect IR back to the filament of an incandescent bulb is probably not going to be cost-effective. Photonic crystals have detailed structure like an IC, with waveguides and cavities, and are made by similar methods. That's a lot to make just to get an IR mirror for a light bulb, since you'd need a large surface area of the material. Probably more expensive than fabbing LEDs. This sounds like an interesting development overhyped by the PR staff. Again. See [2]. [1] http://ab-initio.mit.edu/photons/ http://ab-initio.mit.edu/photons/ [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10916894 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10916894
- neltnerb 11y agoNah, I bet this can be done with a 1D photonic crystal where they can get away with simply using alternating layers of uniform thin film thickness. I forget exactly but I'd think all that's needed is alternating dielectric constant materials with a periodicity ~700nm which isn't that crazy. More expensive than glass sure, but it's not like it'll need special etching to get microlenses.
- neltnerb 11y agoFWIW, slide 21 from this presentation on the site you linked has the picture I have in mind since at that size scale the glass is effectively flat. http://ab-initio.mit.edu/photons/tutorial/L1-bloch.pdf http://ab-initio.mit.edu/photons/tutorial/L1-bloch.pdf Feel free to correct if this is oversimple, I am vaguely familiar with this stuff but it was by no means a speciality.
- Animats 11y agoThat sounds like an ordinary bandpass interference filter.[1] Those have film layers and only pass a specific wavelength of light. Unlike ordinary filters, the angle at which the light hits the filter affects the passband, because it's the spacing of the layers that makes it work. The receive side of LIDAR systems use those. But those absorb the light they reject; they don't reflect it, much. [1] http://www.edmundoptics.com/optics/optical-filters/bandpass-filters/infrared-bandpass-interference-filters/3430/ http://www.edmundoptics.com/optics/optical-filters/bandpass-...
- neltnerb 11y agoGotcha, that makes sense. I suppose most of it will come from a narrow solid angle so if it were perfectly spherical you'd be okay but that would only work for the first reflection unless it was all reflection and no emission...
- OopsCriticality 11y agoIt reminds me of the halogen infrared (HIR) bulbs used for automotive lighting. I'm not clear on what advantage a theoretical mass-produced photonic crystal bulb would offer for this application that HIR does not. Any thoughts?
- sqldba 11y agoIt will be interesting; but I'd pay a little more to have that nice yellow incandescent light in my house without the whopping electricity bill to boot.
- jacobolus 11y agoI sure hope so. Incandescent bulbs are much more pleasant than any fluorescents and the vast majority of LEDs on the market.
- wyldfire 11y agoAren't LEDs and CFLs significantly more durable than incandescent? Certainly they're more durable than tungsten-filament incandescent bulbs. Hopefully they can do better than just parity with LED/CFL power consumption otherwise it wouldn't seem worthwhile.
- jacobolus 11y agoWhat do you mean durable? If you leave an incandescent and a CFL on continuously, the CFL lasts much longer. If you take both and turn them on and off over and over repeatedly, the CFL doesn’t have the same advantage. The CFL is also much more expensive to produce, and much more difficult to dispose of. This is a pretty reasonable list of complaints about CFL lamps. http://www.richsoil.com/CFL-fluorescent-light-bulbs.jsp http://www.richsoil.com/CFL-fluorescent-light-bulbs.jsp (Many of the other sites around the web complaining about CFLs are full of wacky exaggerations.)
- Spooky23 11y agoCFLs and some LED lamps are very heat sensitive. Some are engineered to only operate in an upright position. If you have fixtures other than table lamps, like wall sconces, CFLs usually suck.
- Spooky23 11y agoSupposedly they last forever, but they don't seem to deliver on the supposed 10+ year lifespans -- I have no bulb older then 3 years in my house.
- mrbill 11y agoOut of 12 bulbs, I've had three of the CREE LED bulbs from Home Depot fail in a "disco strobe" mode in less than six months :(
- Spooky23 11y agoI actually gave up and bought a bunch of incandescent bulbs at a clearance sale. Even accounting for wasted energy, financially I'll be in the black for 5-7 years based on my experience with CFL/LED fail.
- prewett 11y agoCool idea, but these sound difficult to manufacture efficiently, given that you need to grow precise layers of crystal on the filament. On the other hand, you know are living in the high-tech future when even your light bulbs require a clean room!
- jjoonathan 11y agoIn the age of $0.35 16MHz ARM cores (I'm sure you can get them much cheaper, that's just what I found on digikey) a bit of process complexity might not be so prohibitive. What a time to be alive!
- SwellJoe 11y agoWhy doesn't everything have a supercomputer (circa 1985) built into it? At $0.35, why not!?
- Alex3917 11y agoBecause thinking of uses for computers now costs at least 1,000x more than the computers themselves.
- driverdan 11y agoBecause it's completely pointless in most cases. The "Internet of Shit" Twitter account[1] may be satire but it highlights this unnecessary use of technology. 1: https://twitter.com/internetofshit https://twitter.com/internetofshit
- TD-Linux 11y agoBecause a low voltage power supply for the micro is quite expensive generally, compared to everything else. Plus you're probably adding a PCB and more BOM parts. There are some ways to make cheap non isolated supplies, but then the microcontroller can't be wired to any external low voltage I/o. Of course, if you already have a PCB and power supply, then it makes total sense and most products that meet this criteria are microcontroller based.
- 11y ago
- jrapdx3 11y agoThis development was discussed on HN about 3 days ago. On that thread I commented that a merit of the incandescent is its continuous output spectrum. The newer lamp technologies produce discontinuous spectral output, CFL having prominent green, and LED blue emissions. The difference is reflected in the CRI (Color Rendering Index) where 100 represents natural daylight. Incandescent lamps are generally very close to 100, but most fluorescent and LED sources are much lower, 90 or less. CRI is crucially important in the visual arts (museum/gallery lighting, photography, etc.) and other industries (color matching). There are fluorescent and recently LED lamps that have high CRI ratings. These are relatively expensive items different from the "bulbs" sold at the hardware store. For the future, "remote phosphor" LED lamps look promising, though likely there will be a market for improved incandescents as described in the article. Looks like advancements in LED, and now incandescent, technology could produce lamps that provide the best of both worlds: high CRI along with significantly extended durability.
- darkmighty 11y agoNote that due to how CRIs are calculated, you can have an arbitrarily bad color rendition even with any CRI <100 with discontinuous spectra: if your object reflects mostly on the bands where the spectrum is weak, it will appear black (or you could have a daylight e.g. red object appear e.g. blue or any other color). That's why incandescents are really the standard for color rendition.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoHigh CRI white LEDs have been a thing for a while though. While not completely continuous the high CRI GE "reveal" lights are pretty good [1]. [1] http://www.cnet.com/news/shining-a-light-on-high-cri-led-bulbs/ http://www.cnet.com/news/shining-a-light-on-high-cri-led-bul...
- amluto 11y agoI bought and returned a GE Reveal bulb. High CRI or not, it rendered colors terribly. Slate green turned purple. Bluish paint did something else nasty -- I forget exactly. It didn't look at all like incandescents, daylight, or other LEDs. We returned it and tried a high CRI Cree lamp. It looked normal.
- donatj 11y agoI've always wondered how efficient are traditional bulbs as an actual heat source? I live in Minnesota and its -17°F outside, and would it be more energy efficient to heat the room I am currently occupying with the light bulbs of the room, keeping the rest of the house cooler than pumping a higher level of heat to the entire house? I feel like the switch to CFLs may have increased my energy bills overall.
- repsilat 11y agoThey're somewhere in the vicinity of 100% efficient as heat producers. Even the energy that goes into producing light just decays into heat after bouncing off a couple of walls. Less "efficient" than using a "heat pump," and possibly more expensive than using gas (I don't know anything about energy in Minnesota). If you're using electricity to heat your home, though, you might as well use something like SETI@home and put it to use :-)
- tempestn 11y agoUnfortunately you can't use a heat pump (at least a normal one) below about -8C (17F), so -17F would definitely be out. I also don't know anything about energy in Minnesota, but here in BC, gas heating is still cheaper than electric, especially if you use an efficient gas furnace (that doesn't exhaust too much heat), but not as much as it used to be. (Technically though it will always be less "efficient" than electric due to that exhaust, but that's really comparing apples to oranges.)
- lscharen 11y agoThat's true for air heat pumps, but many people (myself included) have ground water heat pump systems; either open- or closed-loop. My unit is fairly old (mid 1980 Tetco) and provide all of our heating and cooling. It uses the most electricity in January/February for heating and July/August for cooling, but my total electric bill is usually never more than $200/mo and that included all of the home's "normal" electricity use.
- danans 11y ago
- jhallenworld 11y agoMy LED bulbs work well (Philips), but have one flaw: they do not redden when you dim them. I would like the color temperature to be much lower than 2700K when they are dim- to more approximate an oil lamp. Anyway, perhaps this work will lead to efficient incandescent bulbs that provide nicer light when dimmed.
- kup0 11y agoDoes this address the short lifespans of incandescent bulbs? Since the filament portion is essentially the same, wouldn't these new bulbs suffer from this same issue, and wouldn't that make them less efficient overall due to replacement costs and waste?