4 ms·
If that's true why do scientists take seti seriously and ask to increase its funding? The attitude has always baffled me in fact. We constantly say that alien
by mrfusion 11y ago
If that's true why do scientists take seti seriously and ask to increase its funding?
The attitude has always baffled me in fact. We constantly say that alien life is likely due to the size of the universe yet we can't use them as an explanation for observed phenomenon.
- Sharlin 11y agoA hypothesis that makes testable predictions is perfectly valid science even if it involves aliens. "Aliens did it" in itself is not a scientific explanation. Aluen life is probable a priori just given the size of the universe; unfortunately we also have all sorts of other evidence that technological alien civilizations are nowhere near us. With SETI, we explicitly make the assumption that any prospective aliens are using communications technology that can be intercepted by us.
- charlesdm 11y ago> With SETI, we explicitly make the assumption that any prospective aliens are using communications technology that can be intercepted by us. And they probably are not. :-)
- mcv 11y agoThat's what I suspect. From what I understand, we wouldn't be able to detect our own radio broadcasts from more than half a light year away. The only realistic way in which we might detect alien radio signals is if they were either really close, or they're using a focused beam aimed directly at us. Which would imply they know we're here and listening. It all seems a bit unlikely. Detecting alien megastructures, though, there might be something to that.
- greglindahl 11y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. That's why you'll see researchers working hard on all of the ordinary explanations of an observation, for a long time, before entertaining an extraordinary explanation.
- cnp 11y agoAnd it is extraordinary claims that sometimes spur the imagination towards scientific action. Creativity works in many forms.
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago"A plausible model" is the key phrase. There's a huge difference between postulating that aliens might exist and produce radio broadcasts (something which we can already do, and understand very well) and that aliens might exist and be able to not only build something larger than a hundred planets, but build it in ten years. We don't even have a theory about the sort of engineering that might be required for that--it's pure speculation. And that's the problem.
- cthalupa 11y ago>but build it in ten years. A hundred years, actually. I made the same mistake reading the article and had to do a double take.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoAh, indeed. Fair point. I think my argument still stands, though--even a hundred years for something of this scale is beyond any science we can reasonably hypothesize about. Doesn't mean we can't speculate, just that it's not terribly constructive speculation.