5 ms·
If there's no plausible model that involves aliens and explains the observations, it's not science. "Advanced aliens did it in a way we don't understand" is bas
by Sharlin 11y ago
If there's no plausible model that involves aliens and explains the observations, it's not science. "Advanced aliens did it in a way we don't understand" is basically a "Goddidit" argument.
- puredemo 11y agoAliens of the gaps? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps
- sandworm101 11y agoThere is a difference between claiming that aliens have done something, and being critical of those too dismissive of the possibility. This isn't goddidit. That argument is used to end a debate, to say that the how is unknowable. A claim that aliens are doing something is the opposite, a call for more careful and complete scientific scrutiny.
- Sharlin 11y agoThe time to investigate outlandish hypotheses is after the space of more plausible ones is exhausted.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSo let's hear some more plausible ones. If you assert that no intelligent extraterrestrial entities are capable of harnessing, redirecting, or otherwise manipulating the light from a star, then you have a burden of proof of your own to meet.
- titzer 11y agoI think the burden of proof is heavy and squarely on those who propose so lightly that "advanced aliens" do such things.
- CamperBob2 11y agoThere's plenty of "burden of proof" to go around, I think. That's what makes this such an interesting (if futile) question. It comes down to the amount of surprise we should experience at finding evidence of any ET civilization. Arguably, given the sheer number of other worlds that we now know to exist, it's surprising that we haven't found any such evidence. At the same time, given the vast distances involved, it would be surprising if any evidence that we might find didn't consist of something truly unusual and spectacular on a stellar scale... something like a Dyson structure that only one in a million civilizations might be capable of creating. With our current observational tech, we'd never notice anything less. In the OP, Sharlin used the term "outlandish." That's a value judgement, not a term of art. It's a judgment we're not qualified to make.
- jerf 11y agoIn Occam's Razor terms, "super-sophisticated aliens did it" is just about the most complicated answer with the most "entities" conceivable. It is a great deal simpler to hypothesize that we've missed some aspect of stellar dynamics that fits the observations. This is further boosted by the fact that we have a history of such things (pulsars, etc). It may be true, but it is definitely a hypothesis sitting on the bottom of the list of sensible possibilities. Any rational analysis pretty much has to put "our understanding of stellar dynamics is missing something" multiple orders of magnitude more likely, given our current state of information.
- CamperBob2 11y agoIn Occam's Razor terms, "super-sophisticated aliens did it" is just about the most complicated answer with the most "entities" conceivable. Occam's Razor isn't a nuclear weapon. You still have to decide which entities are necessary and which are superfluous, presumably through some insight into the underlying premises. In this case we simply don't have the perspective we need to decide what's "outlandish" (to use Sharlin's term) and what isn't. What's inherently outlandish about aliens? We're aliens, too, from the perspective of every other civilization that might exist. See my other post -- some very credible authorities would say it's surprising that we haven't found evidence of any ET civilizations, given the number of possible habitats for them. What's almost certain is that the only such civilizations we could observe are the few who can deliberately alter the appearance of a star. Not only is it scientifically inappropriate to reject "Aliens did it!" as a hypothesis or to assign it an arbitrary (un)likelihood, but IMO we shouldn't even be surprised if that turns out to be the case. Alien civilizations are, or should be, no big deal.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThe aliens are superfluous entities because "aliens did it by unknown mechanisms" has no additional explanatory power than "it occured by unknown mechanisms."
- CamperBob2 11y ago
- evo_9 11y agoSo let's entirely dismiss this possibility even though we have no idea what it is? That seems equally unreasonable.
- dragonwriter 11y agoEh, outlandish hypotheses can be worth exploring once they exist as scientific hypotheses, i.e., when there is something that forms a basis for a falsifiable prediction, even if more mundane explanations haven't been rejected. OTOH, "aliens did it by unknown means" is experimentally undistinguishable from "it happened by unknown mechanisms" more generally, and untestable.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mrfusion 11y agoIf that's true why do scientists take seti seriously and ask to increase its funding? The attitude has always baffled me in fact. We constantly say that alien life is likely due to the size of the universe yet we can't use them as an explanation for observed phenomenon.
- Sharlin 11y agoA hypothesis that makes testable predictions is perfectly valid science even if it involves aliens. "Aliens did it" in itself is not a scientific explanation. Aluen life is probable a priori just given the size of the universe; unfortunately we also have all sorts of other evidence that technological alien civilizations are nowhere near us. With SETI, we explicitly make the assumption that any prospective aliens are using communications technology that can be intercepted by us.
- charlesdm 11y ago> With SETI, we explicitly make the assumption that any prospective aliens are using communications technology that can be intercepted by us. And they probably are not. :-)
- mcv 11y agoThat's what I suspect. From what I understand, we wouldn't be able to detect our own radio broadcasts from more than half a light year away. The only realistic way in which we might detect alien radio signals is if they were either really close, or they're using a focused beam aimed directly at us. Which would imply they know we're here and listening. It all seems a bit unlikely. Detecting alien megastructures, though, there might be something to that.
- greglindahl 11y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary proof. That's why you'll see researchers working hard on all of the ordinary explanations of an observation, for a long time, before entertaining an extraordinary explanation.
- Almaviva 11y agoI think your view of what science is is a little too narrow. "Aliens did it in a way we don't understand, yet" is a hypothesis, which could be supported or refuted. The famous quote by Asimov is 'The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not "Eureka" but "That's funny..."' We've got something funny here, which may be (probably is?) nothing new, or may be exciting.
- dragonwriter 11y agoIt is a conjecture or speculation; it is not a hypothesis, in the scientific sense, because without something more than "some way we don't understand", it makes no falsifiable predictions of future observations. Now, speculation of this type can be the starting point to developing a testable hypothesis, so its not completely outside the scientific process, but it's far sorry of even a hypothesis.
- Almaviva 11y agoThanks for the point, I agree if we're speaking precisely and not colloquially. But... > "its not completely outside the scientific process" Here you unfairly (imo) diminish the role of wonder and speculation in science, which isn't something at the fringes of it, but part of the very soul and essence of it.
- marvin 11y agoThere is an unfortunate side effect of the rationalism movement that the (mostly correct) dismissal of religious explanations and pseudoscientific ideas: A lot of people who should know better also dismiss philosophy, conjecture and other ideas that don't have a firmly established theory as unscientific. These things are an important part of the scientific process. A lot of the key scientific tools and knowledge we have today started out as philosophical riddles. Ironically, this same mistake has been made time and time again throughout history when science has made great strides. Someone points out that "that's funny", and are immediately shot down for coming up with ridiculous ideas that are not supported by the current theories. This might not describe OP, but it's a pretty common phenomenon that often shows up in discussions where the boundaries of our current scientific knowledge are close. E.g. AI, the un-observable part of the universe, experiments that seem to break physics (e.g. the RF resonant cavity thruster), what is consciousness, etc.
- namlem 11y agoBut there are plausible ways they could have done it. They could, for example, be redirecting the IR radiation in some other direction.