4 ms·
You lie just to make things slightly easier for yourself, and you think this is OK?
by mikeash 11y ago
You lie just to make things slightly easier for yourself, and you think this is OK?
- lloyd-christmas 11y agoYes. 100% and unequivocally yes. I don't understand how you could think that's wrong. When doing hiring, my job isn't to make you feel good about yourself or give everyone an equal chance. It's to _filter out talent_. I have better things to do than sift through 1000 extra resumes from people who don't even think themselves qualified.
- invalidOrTaken 11y agoWhat are your thoughts on new hires who, when you tell them something, don't believe you, on the principle that you've lied to them before? Alternately: if we were to try and write this function: fn isStatementTrue (statement){ } and apply it to your statements to jobseekers and employees, how many lines of code would be necessary for it to achieve a 99% accuracy rate?
- lloyd-christmas 11y agoWhen I'm hungry and I go to the fridge, I'm reasonably confident that when I open the door, I'm not going to start chewing on a stick of butter or bite into an onion. That doesn't mean I know what I want to eat. Filtering out what you don't want is a lot different than choosing what you do want, and you treat them differently. Both parties know that. I don't care about being an asshole to a sheet of paper than floats onto my desk on its way to the shredder. I'd never act like an asshole in an interview. If they are in the room, they are a potential coworker and will be treated as if they are already one. Your statement can't be applied to jobseekers and employees. They aren't the same Type.
- mikeash 11y agoYou don't understand how I could think that lying for selfish reasons is wrong?
- lloyd-christmas 11y agoMaybe you could explain to me why you think that's selfish. Here's why I don't see it as selfish: Hiring is expensive. My time has a numerical number attached to it. As a tangible example, my revenue for my company is $125 an hour. I ended up interviewing 10 people for our most recent junior level hire. 2 of them were duds, immediately costing the company $250. The rest of them each spent about 2.5 hours with me: $2500. 4 were invited back, spending about 4 hours each with me: $2000. 1 was invited back to spend the day with me pair programming. I'll discount this at half price, given that I was still able to accomplish something: $500. They didn't end up taking the job offer, so I invited my second choice in for the same deal: $500. I ended up hiring them. 10 people cost the company $5,750. Read back through what I wrote, and you'll notice I said "I". I'm solely talking about my contribution to being in an interview room, not even accounting for my coworkers' contributions, nor the time spent with resumes. Now read back through it again, and replace "company" with "fellow employees". My "selfish" approach saves my coworkers money by eliminating candidates who were statistically unlikely to get the job anyway. If that's truly selfish, sign me up any day of the week. For some more context, go flip through linkedIn profiles of people with <5 years of work experience and you'll see a strong trend: (5 months) (5 months) (3 months) (7 months). Not even 2 years and 4 "full time" jobs. Going back to the hiring numbers, intro_to_hiring puts the cost of replacement equal to their salary. Now imagine my hire follows this trend. I've spent $15k on finding them, $10k on training them, $40k in salary, and now I have to spend another $80k replacing them. All of that in a span of 6 months. Sounds like a pretty one-sided deal. All said and done, I struggle to believe I'm the selfish asshole of the story.
- mikeash 11y agoIt doesn't become better or somehow "not selfish" just because you bring your coworkers into it. It is ultimately the company which is lying for selfish reasons. The company lies about its requirements to save money. And you don't understand how I could think that's wrong? You seem to not even grasp what I have a problem with, since you spend your entire final paragraph talking about the perils of hiring inexperienced people. I have no problem with companies saying they want 3+ years of experience because they don't want inexperienced people. That's totally fine. Where I have a problem is when you say "3+ years" but actually want 1+ years, as you described in your original comment. Not only is that dishonest, but it selects for dishonest applicants, since scrupulous people with 1-2 years of experience will not respond to your ad, while unscrupulous people will. Again, I have no problem with experience requirements, I merely have a problem with lying about them as you said you do. If you reply, please keep that in mind, and don't explain why experience is so important, because that's not the issue.
- jschwartzi 11y agoWhat company do you hire for? I never want to work there.