3 ms·
I was shocked to learn (on the news this morning) that 2 WalMart stores in the Bay Area are closing (Oakland and San Jose (Monterey Highway)). I don't know ther
by rconti 11y ago
I was shocked to learn (on the news this morning) that 2 WalMart stores in the Bay Area are closing (Oakland and San Jose (Monterey Highway)). I don't know there were ANY until a week or two ago when I did a Google Maps search.
My hatred of them goes back to my youth and early online activism from when WalMart was pushing out local mom and pop record stores in small towns and replacing them with their shitty censored versions of music. (WalMart insisted that labels manufacture and sell censored copies just so they could push their twisted morals on America).
Needless to say, nothing they have done in the past twenty years has made them any more deserving of my dollars. I've never bought anything there and never will. Fortunately we live in an area of the country where it's easier to avoid them than it is to shop there, even if you wanted to.
- refurb 11y agoWalMart was pushing out local mom and pop record stores in small towns and replacing them with their shitty censored versions of music. How would Walmart put these stores out of business? Or do you mean consumers did by shopping at Walmart instead?
- influx 11y agoThey had cheaper prices, which means poor people could buy more goods with their paycheck. It's weird they would shop there instead.
- rconti 11y agoIt's about using their power to create and push an inferior product (censored music created especially for WalMart). At the time (early-mid 90s) I was a teenager, so it was a big deal that others who couldn't drive no longer had the option to buy proper versions of music thanks to WalMart's heavy hand. WalMart shoppers vote with their dollars, and so do I.
- superuser2 11y agoWalmart's MO was/is to beat the prices of local businesses, operating at a loss (subsidized by other stores), until those businesses die. Then it can jack prices back up.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 11y agoThey had a playbook for crushing both small local retailers and regional chains. A big part of it was selling stuff at a loss and getting around zoning rules by dropping stores in outlying areas outside of towns, extracting tax concessions in the process. As the GP mentioned, they were selective in stocking of books, CDs and other media. Lots of Jesus stuff and "family friendly" fare, which kept the local ministers and conservatives happy. They also used their distribution as a weapon -- their market power let them cut national deals with big vendors like P&G and actually make them rent space on WalMart trucks. Walmart would expand by building multiple stores in a region, surrounding denser communities. Doing that and exploiting those national accounts let them flood the region with goods, and kill the regional distributors that traditional discount stores and local stores depended on. Once the competition is dead, prices float back up. We're all stuck with a shitty shopping experience and high prices. Now they use their dominant position to extract direct and indirect government subsidy on top of everything else. The company may be a triumph of some version of capitalism, but they are a cancer on society.
- refurb 11y agoDo you have any evidence to backup your claims? Are they "crushing both small local retailers and regional chains" or just competing with them? Would it have been better had they not competed? And yes, Walmart drove hard bargains with their suppliers. Why not? They were offering those suppliers a ton of business. If the suppliers didn't like the deal, they didn't have to take it. I just disagree that Walmart is a bad thing at all. Like I said, nobody is forced to shop there. If customers didn't like it, they could continue to shop at their mom-and-pop stores, but the important thing to note is they didn't.
- Spooky23 11y agoYou live in a place where that's true. Many places have Walmart, gas stations or a 60 mile drive to a bigger city. Since the outcome of WalMart's success is duopoly between Target and WalMart, I would say that no, we're not better off. This was a huge topic in the 90s, I'd suggest that you look at the many published descriptions of their business practices.
- bdcravens 11y agoDo you share the same hatred for Best Buy, Amazon, Barnes and Noble, etc?
- hacknat 11y agoTagging Amazon with the same world-dominating price cutting that Walmart has practiced is a little bit unfair, as they offer a lot of other unique things a long side of just purchasing stuff. The most notable feature being that you don't have to leave your house to buy stuff. Are there many small businesses competing on these terms? If a service exists that allows me to save my time by not having to schlep myself to some store across town only to find that what I wanted is out of stock, or doesn't fit, or etc, then isn't it my prerogative to take advantage of it? Indeed, isn't the burden of proof on the companies that don't offer this to explain why I should shop there? Amazon beats the competition on prices, selection, ease-of-use, logistics, and customer service, but I'm a bad person for buying from them? Oh let's not forget that the vast majority of mom-and-pop stores aren't offering insurance or benefits to their employees, selling mostly ethically sourced products (not saying Amazon does, just that most other people don't either), or finding ways to reduce their supply-chain footprint. I'm not trying to say that Amazon is a saint, but let's not idealize everyone that isn't a huge corporation. People are people.
- rconti 11y agoNo. I am not aware of either one creating a market for censorship. Though I've only ever spent a handful of dollars at Best Buy anyway.