2 ms·
This may be conspiracy theoryish but pieces aren't as far fetched as it might seem. Articles like that in the New York times don't happen by chance and Mike He
by CyberDildonics 11y ago
This may be conspiracy theoryish but pieces aren't as far fetched as it might seem. Articles like that in the New York times don't happen by chance and Mike Hearn being more high profile and vocal than ever is a bit strange. Why would someone make themselves a lightning rod to say that they quit?
I will say that there is a likelyhood that large financial companies aren't so intent on destroying bitcoin. They may be interested in using the same techniques to speed up all the slow and opaque settlement networks so they can adopt enough advantages of crypto-currencies before they are so widespread that no one needs monolithic companies with exclusivity in their capabilities.
At the same time anyone who is a middle man in the financial industry is making money for nothing and won't give that up without trying anything they can.
I think it will turn out to be more akin to AOL trying to be the internet, or AT&T trying to make their own network. Their technology will likely not be great, but the ecosystem surrounding an open system will ultimately be overwhelming and impossible to compete with.
- HillRat 11y agoFIs are very interested in Bitcoin, except for the Bitcoin part, which leads to lots of talk about trying to use blockchains for various unconvincing purposes. The problem is that btc isn't suitable for large financial products, because it's an illiquid, volatile virtual asset with a market-wide price floor of zero. If FIs thought there was a bounded-risk revenue stream to be extracted from Bitcoin, rest assured they'd be doing it -- you'd see efforts to increase liquidity (more than one Bitcoin millionaire, I think, would be willing to pay ten to fifteen points to convert significant fractions of their cryptotokens to fiat currency), hedge products, and so on. The fact that you don't see that suggests that FIs can't figure out how to value btc in a way that the downside doesn't far outstrip the upside potential. Theoretically btc could become so commonly-held and widespread enough that they gain stability through ubiquity (like gold and gems), but I think the problems outlined in the original post -- specifically the fact that a small number of maintainers control the protocol, and, more damningly, that almost all the hashing power in the system is controlled by set of individuals who could trivially collude -- make that less likely than it seemed a few years ago.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoPlenty of what you are saying is true but > specifically the fact that a small number of maintainers control the protocol, Is not all that fundamental. Really the miners control the protocol and it seems that the big companies involved and the miners have enough of the destructive tactics of the blockstream guys. > that almost all the hashing power in the system is controlled by set of individuals who could trivially collude This isn't really true either. There are large pools, but as soon as a pool goes rogue, they will lose the mining power that makes them up and never get it back, since they don't own the machines themselves. Fundamentally though all of this is about the big picture. Bitcoin can't replace large financial products now, but eventually some crypto-currency could. The big finance companies could get together and make their own shared ledger, which might work well for them, but there isn't much reason they couldn't achieve similar effects already. If they create their own currency, that could be a big deal however, because they could gradually put more and more resources into it. The core issue though, is that a blockchain without mining is either not open to anyone or not secure, and without a currency attached to it, the incentives to mine are unknown to me.