3 ms·
True. However, he is in good company: didn't Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak start out the same way when they sold their blue boxing devices? Imagine the iPad anno
by Tichy 17y ago
True. However, he is in good company: didn't Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak start out the same way when they sold their blue boxing devices? Imagine the iPad announcement coming from a prison cell...
- tptacek 17y agoPeople have done real prison time for phone phreaking.
- Tichy 17y agoI am not saying it's not a crime or that the hacker here shouldn't be punished. Just playing devil's advocate.
- tptacek 17y agoIt's also a different world now. You could make a couple bucks on the side in the late '70s and still (sometimes) get away with it, because the problems with our infrastructure hadn't been fully criminalized. We live in a world today where some significant percentage of all bank transactions in some countries are fraudulent. We've officially lost our sense of humor.
- lsc 17y agoI think some responsibility needs to be borne by those creating blatantly insecure systems. If I leave my garage door open and you come in and steal a server, sure, that's illegal, but if, say, I lock my garage door, (or otherwise take reasonable precautions) you break a window, and then steal the same server, your penalty will be greater. depending on equipment on the consumer premises to be secure (especially if your system is so weak as to just look at the mac address.) sounds to me a lot like leaving the garage door open. I think this goes doubly for the banking systems; right now, all I need in order to hover all the money out of your bank account is your checking account number (and a merchant account) and your checking account number is on every cheque you write. That's a ridiculously insecure system, and sure, it should be illegal to exploit that, but I think the banks are 'leaving the garage door open' here - they bear responsibility for not taking reasonable precautions.
- tptacek 17y agoThe definition of "blatantly insecure" is highly subjective. I don't think most app developers want to be held to my standard of "highly secure", and I'm a second-tier vulnerability researcher.