6 ms·
What is frustrating as always is that they invoke criminals and terrorists (and for once no reference to paedophiles!) but these laws will be used 99% of the ti
by cm2187 11y ago
What is frustrating as always is that they invoke criminals and terrorists (and for once no reference to paedophiles!) but these laws will be used 99% of the time in civil cases (divorce cases, etc) and against petty crime. I remember when the UK used the terrorism act to freeze the assets of Icelandic banks. Terrorism has just become the keyword law enforcement officials add to the title of any law they want to see passed, no question ask.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7688560.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7688560.stm
- matthewmacleod 11y agoThis isn't really related to your main point, but it's disingenuous to describe the freezing of Landbanki's assets as a use of the "terrorism act" just because the legislation had "anti-terrorism" in the title. The Anti-Terrorism, Crime and Security Act is pretty wide-ranging, and as well as whatever anti-terror legislation it contains, also contains some legislation around economic security - which is what was used in the case of Icesave.
- cm2187 11y agoThat's actually precisely my point. Voted immediately after 9/11, it's a prime example of a law titled "anti-terrorism" which actually has a much broader range and provides powers in domains that have nothing to do whatsoever with terrorism.
- SN76477 11y agoAlmost like some sort of conspiracy.
- adrianlmm 11y ago>but these laws will be used 99% of the time in civil cases (divorce cases, etc) Would that be a bad thing?, so you are implying that encryption is wanted to actually hide crimes or unloyal behavior mostly?
- gruez 11y agoThe problem is that the public is misled about what the law is going to be used for. Mandatory decryption will get much less support if the electorate knows it's going to be used for non-terrorism related crimes.
- adrianlmm 11y agoBut will still be used to fight crime, so?
- cm2187 11y agoNot everything courts deal with is crime. A divorce case isn't about crime (and I bet they will be major consumers of decrypting devices, looking for nasty pictures or conversations!). The president investigating who in his administration is talking to the press isn't about crime.
- adrianlmm 11y ago>(and I bet they will be major consumers of decrypting devices, looking for nasty pictures or conversations!). OK, and why would that be a bad thing? if it is done in the context of a case investigation.
- spdustin 11y ago#1) because in many jurisdictions it has no bearing on the divorce itself, and #2) in many jurisdictions a person who flirts with a consenting adult over text hasn't actually committed any crime in doing so Which leads to... #3) what is the point of decrypting said personal communications except to vindicate the estranged party's already fully-formed assumption that their spouse is a wicked person, or to exact some kind of court-sanctioned revenge. I swear, sometimes in threads like this it's hard to tell if someone is trolling or legitimately can't ponder the unintended (or, perhaps, fully intended but thinly veiled) consequences of laws that serve to grant the state access to private communications.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]